Gui Ruiyan

Apollonius of Perga · 佩尔加的阿波罗尼奥斯
Conics · 圆锥曲线论

A Study of the Synonymity between Hyperbola and Ellipse in Proposition 21, Book I

Paper / 论文

To answer why an hyperbola can sometimes be treated synonymously with an ellipse, my hypothesis is that the commonalities shared by the two figures are revealed by Proposition 12 and 13 in Book I. For it is in these propositions that the definition of an hyperbola and that of an ellipse are first laid out. The essential difference and similarity between the two figures, therefore, can only be most originarily determined through an understanding of these two propositions.

The definition of an hyperbola as formulated in Proposition 12, and here summarized by me, determines that an hyperbola is a conic section the square on the ordinate of which is equal to the rectangle contained by the abscissa corresponding to the ordinate and the upright side plus a figure projected beyond it, a figure that is ‘similar and similarly situated to the rectangle contained by the straight line subtending the exterior angle of the [vertex of the axial] triangle and by the parameter’. The parameter is what is later known as the upright side, and ‘the straight line subtending the exterior angle of the [vertex of the axial] triangle’ is nothing other than the transverse side.

If we read Proposition 13, we find that the definition of an ellipse is structurally the same. I summarize the definition to the following: an ellipse is such a conic section the square on the ordinate of which is equal to the rectangle contained by the abscissa corresponding to the ordinate and the upright side minus a figure projected within it, a figure that is similar and similarly situated to the rectangle contained by the transverse side and the upright side. And if we be more careful, and see if the upright side in an ellipse is determined in a similar way as it is determined in an hyperbola, we find that it is indeed the case. For the upright side in both cases is constructed according to a proportion between the same terms in the same order, namely the transverse side to the upright side should be the same as the square (on the line which is parallel to the cutting plane and is produced from the vertex of the cone to its base) to the rectangle (contained by the line connecting one end of the base of the axial triangle to the intersection point between the base and the aforesaid line which is parallel to the cutting plane, and by the line connecting the other end of the base of the axial triangle to the same intersection point). And the transverse side of an hyperbola seems not essentially different from that of an ellipse, for each signifies the distance between the two cuts the cutting plane makes on the section along the same diameter. Moreover, the diameter is defined in First Definitions as that straight line which, ‘drawn from the curved line, bisects all straight lines drawn to this curved line parallel to some straight line’. The diameters of all sections, including those of parabolas, share the same definition. But parabolas do not have a transverse side, for its diameter does not cut the conic section at two places, hence not prescribing the definite distance between two cuts which is the transverse. Therefore, it is reasonable to conclude backwards that, since an hyperbola and an ellipse share the same definition of a diameter, and unlike a parabola, they both have a transverse side on their diameter, the determination of their respective transverse sides being essentially one, other terms of the determining proportion being also equivalent, their determination of the upright side should essentially be one. Since both definitions of the two figures are dependent upon the determination of the upright side, other things being the same, their definitions should belong together. The difference between the two propositions is therefore one of expression, not one of essence.

To test my hypothesis, I now turn to Proposition 21 where the hyperbola and the ellipse are treated synonymously. This proposition aims at proving that within a non-parabola section, the square on its ordinate is to the rectangle contained by ‘the straight lines cut off by [the ordinate] beginning from the ends of the transverse side of the figure as the upright side of the figure is to the transverse’. In an hyperbola, one end of the transverse is the vertex of the section, while the other end of the transverse is outside the section, being the vertex of the opposite section. In an ellipse, however, both ends of the transverse are on the closed figure. While ‘the straight lines cut off by the ordinate’, later named as the ‘abscissae’, share one same definition of a distance between the vertex and the cutting points on the diameter in both cases, there remains the difference that, in an hyperbola, one of the abscissae is expressed as the transverse plus the other abscissa, whereas in an ellipse, one abscissa is expressed as the transverse minus the other abscissa. However, this difference is not crucial for the first step of Proposition 21, which consists of the establishment of a proportion between the similar triangles. Proportion alone matters here. And since the difference does not alter the fact that similar triangles can be formed based on a projection from the transverse over the upright side, through the ‘determining’ line, this difference is of no importance. In Taliaferro’s figure, the two similar triangles thus formed are Triangle ABC and Triangle GBK. We can see that depending upon whether the transverse is on the outside or the inside of the section, the triangle similar and similarly situated to the triangle formed between the transverse and upright side either exceeds or falls short of the triangle formed between the transverse and upright side. But what matters in this step is simply the proportion that obtains between these two similar triangles, as was said above. Hence regardless of whether the projected triangle exceeds or falls short of the triangle formed between the transverse and upright side, as long as the triangles are similar triangles, the proportion holds. Thus here, so long as both an hyperbola and an ellipse have both the transverse and the upright side, similar triangles can be formed, and the relationship still obtains.

The other condition required of the proof is more specified. For in order to achieve the final substitution of the square on the ordinate by the rectangle contained by the abscissa and by the line drawn parallel (a line thus drawn amounts to Line GK in Taliaferro’s figure) to the upright side through the intersection between the ordinate and the diameter stopping at the ‘determining line’, which is a line connecting the other end of the transverse to the other end of the upright side produced indefinitely, one has to, applying Proposition 12 and 13, first confirm that the said rectangle is identical to the rectangle, in the case of an hyperbola, contained by the corresponding abscissa and the upright side plus a figure projected beyond it, and in the case of an ellipse, to the rectangle contained by the corresponding abscissa and the upright side minus a figure projected within it, whereas in both cases the said projected figure is similar and similarly situated to the rectangle contained by the transverse and upright side.

This identity is confirmed when we see how the figure is ‘determined’. Since similar triangles are constructed along that ‘determining [διορίζουσα] line’, in an hyperbola, the base that corresponds to the upright side of the section in the constructed triangle exceeds the upright side, while in an ellipse, the same base falls short of the upright side. Therefore, in an hyperbola, the rectangle contained by the abscissa and this line ‘drawn parallel to’ the upright side (these formulations on how this line should be drawn I from now on shorten into the term ‘projection’, and the line thus drawn that is the base corresponding to the upright side of the section in the constructed triangle I from now on will call ‘the projected line that is parallel to the upright side’) shall be equal to that area which is the rectangle contained by the abscissa and the upright side plus the projected rectangle, similar and similarly situated to the rectangle contained by the transverse and upright side. For since the triangles constructed in Proposition 21 are similar triangles, the ratio between the excess the projected line that is parallel to the upright side has to the upright side and the abscissa should be equal to the ratio between the upright and the transverse side, as is displayed in the first diagram below (see the diagrams below).

When the abscissa is taken as the common height, the rectangle contained by the projected line that is parallel to the upright side and the abscissa should exceed the rectangle contained by the upright side and the abscissa by a rectangle contained by the excess length and the abscissa, which is equivalent to the figure projected beyond, similar and similarly situated to the rectangle contained by the transverse and upright side. Thus, we see the equivalence between that rectangle contained by the projected line that is parallel to the upright side and the abscissa, and that rectangle contained by the upright side and abscissa plus a rectangle projected beyond, in the case of an hyperbola.

This formulation of a rectangle contained by the projected line that is parallel to the upright side and the abscissa also includes the case of an ellipse. For in an ellipse, the figure is depicted like the second diagram below (see the diagrams below).

Likewise, in the case of an ellipse, the rectangle contained by the projected line that is parallel to the upright side and the abscissa is essentially identical to the area of a rectangle contained by the upright side and the abscissa deficient of a rectangle projected within the figure similar and similarly situated to the rectangle contained by the transverse and upright side. Since this formulation of ‘a projected line that is parallel to the upright side’ is consistent to the scenarios depicted in both cases, it is legitimate to establish the synonymity between the hyperbola and the ellipse in this proposition.

So far, it is implied that because of the multiple commonalities shared between the hyperbola and the ellipse, there are also multiple occasions by which the two figures can be treated in a synonymous way. Depending on the particular end the proposition aims at achieving, the commonality actually used in the proposition might differ in its level of specification. For instance, one commonality might simply be that only the hyperbola and the ellipse have both the upright and transverse side. It could also be like in Proposition 21, where the commonality is further specified as a certain relationship that abscissa holds to the corresponding ordinate, through the mediation of the upright and transverse side. In Proposition 21 we see both at work, for the establishment of the relationship between the similar triangles is only contingent upon the existence of a transverse side. So when both the hyperbola and the ellipse have the transverse side, the synonymity is evident. But with the later determination of the rectangle contained by the projected line that is parallel to the upright side and the abscissa in relation to the square on the ordinate, a further specification of this synonymity needs be clarified. Therefore, what is required is to establish that both the species of ‘the area that is a rectangle contained by the upright side and by the abscissa plus a rectangle that is projected beyond, similar and similarly situated to the rectangle contained by the transverse and upright side’, and the species of ‘the area that is a rectangle contained by the upright side and by the abscissa minus a rectangle that is projected within, similar and similarly situated to the rectangle contained by the transverse and upright side’, belong to the genus of ‘a rectangle contained by the abscissa and the projected line that is parallel to the upright side’. This figure of a higher generality is what the proposition is interested in (to effect the crucial step of the substitution of the square on the ordinate by this figure), and it is this more general figure that becomes the ideated object for this proposition, thus the differences can be overlooked. How such a figure of higher generality can be treated as one object, however, is a much more complex question that has grave philosophical implications.

The first diagram: excess.
The first diagram: excess.
The second diagram: deficiency.
The second diagram: deficiency.