Gui Ruiyan

Aristotle · 亚里士多德
On Memory and Recollection · 论记忆与回忆

Undated 未注日期

On Memory and Recollection — Reading notes

Reflections · Apple Notes

Revised 18 May 2022

In this note / 篇目

On Memory and Recollection

449b 4
Slow people seem better at remembering but fast people seem better at recollecting.

450a 10
It is impossible to think about atemporal things apart from time; understanding necessarily involves an image with magnitude and motion, thus having time. So memory necessarily belongs to the perceptive potency.

450a 20
Things remembered in their own right are imagined; things accompanied by imagination are remembered incidentally.

450b 10
Memory needs to be presented in the present experience, so as to mark the outline of past perceptions into current perceptions. But the problem is what moment are we remembering, now or past?

450b 20
Insofar as the image is in its own right, it’s present; insofar as it’s of something, it’s of the past.

451a 20
There’s difference between remembering and recollection: taking up a memory will create a certain disjointedness from the present experience, which is not occurring with recollection.

451a 30
Taking up a memory cannot happen without passage of time; yet recollection and the thing recollected are present in the soul only in the now. The knowledge recollected is not something of the past.

451b 1
Recollection can be accompanied by memories in the sense that what was experienced and known is now taken up as memory, yet in the present complements with recollection.

451b 10
Recollection implies the source is beyond that by which one learns.

451b 20
Recollection seems to be a grouping of motions of the soul largely simultaneous to each other stimulated by the present so as to recognize the present thing.

452a 1
The motions together with recollection are grouped into a sequence (by habit or by necessity), each unit of which is almost simultaneous to the next one. It has an order, whereas taking up memories seems not necessarily ordered, and this order of recollection is not necessarily a temporal order.

452a 20
The middle is sort of a starting point for recollection.

452a 30
By being at work, a thing that happens often produces a nature. But chance is more likely to be present with things habituated.

452b 10
All inner things are thought in proportion to outer things but smaller, regarding extensive magnitudes. Time can be treated the same way.

452b 30
Two senses of remembering time: 1.one remembers it with a measure, and knows exactly when the thing happened; 2.one remembers it without a measure but in a proportion.

453a 20
Recollection is in some sense bodily.

453a 30
Freudian slip?