Gui Ruiyan

Aristotle · 亚里士多德
Politics · 政治学

Undated 未注日期

Politics — Reading notes

Reflections · Apple Notes

Revised 1 March 2022

In this note / 篇目

1

1252a 30
Origin is more beautiful; a natural striving to leave behind another like itself(procreation); something naturally ruling and ruled for preservation.

1252b 30
The birth of a city for living well. A nature is an end.

1253a 10
Speech is for disclosing what is beneficial and harmful, hence just and unjust.

1253a 20
A whole is more primary than its parts.

1253b 10
What is a skill? How is it different from virtue?

1253b 20
Convention vs nature.

1254a 10
Life is action, not production. Slaves are possessions, possessions are instruments for life; hence slaves are for actions, as well as productions. A natural slave; a possession; a possession belongs wholly to the master as a part belongs to the whole(not just as a part of the whole).

Some rule and ruled pairs are natural; but is this universally valid?

1255a 10
Nature intends to make distinctions; but things often turn out that some people have only the bodies of freemen and master in a bodily manner: is this erotic?

1255a 20
A tension between the just thing and virtue; what predominates is always good in some way, but not necessarily just.

1255b 10
Again, nature does not work the way the law assumes it will intend to do. This interplay between convention and nature is very interesting.

1255b 30
A difference in kinds of knowledge.

1259b 40
Why does this ruling and being ruled distinction have to be in forms?

1260a 20
Virtue is different in kinds; complete virtue only belongs to that which rules.

1260b 1
The slave participates in life so has to share the virtues of the master; the master is then responsible for the slave to a greater extent than the master-craftsman.

This method of looking at a smaller part to conceive of a larger whole is different from the Plato’s method in Republic.

1276a 30
A nation is different from a city.

1277a 1
A citizen’s virtue is different from an excellent man’s virtue; an excellent man aims at the complete virtue, whereas a citizen at that which is good for the city.

1278a 20
The excellent man is different from a good citizen; but an excellent man can be a good citizen since an excellent man, as he is to rule, has to learn rulership through being ruled, and hence partakes of virtues from both sides. Whereas some citizens only obey as slaves and have only virtues of a slave.

1278b 20
The aim of city: to live beautifully together and to live simply.

1279a 20
A city is an association of free people.

1280a 30
An oligarchy is spoken of; but the association of a city is not just an exchange of money for office; but the essential aim is to live well together, hence according to virtue. An exchange is only related to necessity, but not necessarily to the beautiful and good(that is, the happy and self-sufficient for the common whole).

1281b 10
Is this true?

1282a 20
A multitude can be the appropriate judge if they are using the product(rulership).

2

1283a 1
Some goods are not comparable.

1283a 20
Without slaves there are no cities; without freemen there are no beautifully managed cities.

1283b 10
In each form of government who ought to rule as a decision is indisputable but a de facto situation; but it does not mean that it is the best rule.

1284a 1
In the best form of government, a citizen is someone who has the capacity and chooses to be ruled and rule for a life according to virtue.

1284a 10
A god among men, who surpasses others so greatly in virtue; they are laws themselves and surpass the common laws.

1284b 20
A justification for ostracism.

1284b 30
But ostracism of someone of superior virtue is still not altogether just.

1285a 20
Kingship is one right form of government; but why is monarchy, the deviant one, discussed here? Why barbarians?

1287a 20
A law is an orderly arrangement.

1287a 40
A human being is less trustworthy than laws since a human being, in political affairs, often judges by emotions and inclinations; unlike doctors.

1288b 30
A student of politics should study: 1.the best; 2.the best under given conditions; 3.any given city(and its preservation); 4.the common.

1289a 10
Laws should be adapted to forms of government, not the contrary.

1290a 20
A musical metaphor.

1290b 20
A democracy is where the poor are free and many and rule, an oligarchy is where the rich are few and rule.

1291a 30
Whether it’s the same people doing different jobs or different people doing different jobs makes no difference; which is not the case for Plato. Is what is beautiful also something necessary for human beings?

1291a 40
“If indeed it’s impossible to have a city without rulers”.

1292a 10
When the multitude come together as one under demagogues.

1292a 30
Where there is no law, there is no government.

1293a 10
This seems to suggest a degeneration, that as public funding is accumulated, more often the poor rule in person instead of letting the laws rule.

1294b 40
Mixture of both: aristocracy(as the secondary form) is where ruling offices are distributed to the rich and the good, so even the poor who are good can be elected, and thus is mixed with democracy; constitutional rule leans, on the other hand, leans more toward democracy. It should be preserved through itself: none of the parts should want a different form of government.

1295b 10
Too much virtue tends to create insolence?

1324a 10
Happiness in a man is the same as happiness in a city.

1324a 30
Contemplative life or an active political life?

1324b 30
The political art to rule might not be lawful for this particular sort; this is strange for an art which aims at the good.

1325a 1
Master those meant naturally to be mastered.

1325b 10
A person cannot go back to his former self after a vicious action is committed.

1326a 1
Materials for political actions.

With people alike they share in rule and rule in turn; in such cases they obey the rule of others not because their decisions are necessarily better than theirs, but rather that 1.there must be someone ruling in order that decisions be made(to rule out others); 2.it’s beautiful to obey the rule of your equal in turn and hence obey the law. Or, is there a natural urge for each one to rule?