Gui Ruiyan

Michael Faraday · 迈克尔·法拉第
Static Electrical Inductive Action · 静电感应作用

On Faraday’s Researches on Static Electrical Inductive Action

Or, An Analysis on His Letter to Phillips

Paper / 论文

Faraday’s letter to Phillips opens with the following remark: “Perhaps you may think the following experiments worth notice; their value consists in their power to give a very precise and decided idea to the mind respecting certain principles of inductive electrical action, which I find are by many accepted with a degree of doubt or obscurity that takes away much of their importance: they are the expression and proof of certain parts of my view of induction”. The questions that naturally arise are then, first, what are the principles of inductive electrical action?; second, what is Faraday’s view of induction?; and finally, how do experiments demonstrate the truth of his view? In this paper, I shall start from the more accessible things, i.e. experiments and observations, and move to explain how these experiments support Faraday’s theory or why he is convinced they do.

The experiment Faraday starts with is easily devised. An insulated ice-pail is perfectly discharged, its outside connected to a very sensitive electrometer. A charged brass ball, suspended by a dry silk thread, is to be brought into the pail, fulfilling varying conditions. Since the ice-pail is perfectly discharged and insulated, there is no danger of external disturbance on the result. Moreover, one other potential source of error is removed by the ball being suspended by a dry silk thread, which does not conduct, i.e. allow the ball to discharge without touching the pail.

There are three scenarios devised for this experiment. First, the charged ball enters the pail without touching the pail. Second, the charged ball is withdrawn from the pail, without touching the pail. Third, the charged ball enters and touches the pail, and is withdrawn. Three different results are observed from these three different cases. In the first case, the electrometer connected to the outside of the pail reads charge of the same kind as that carried by the ball, the reading gradually increasing in its absolute magnitude as the carrier ball enters, i.e. becoming more positive when the ball is charged positive, negative when the ball is charged negative. The increase in magnitude stops once the ball reaches a certain limit, still without touching the pail. In the second case, the electrometer behaves in reverse to how it behaves in the first case. For if the ball is withdrawn from beyond that limit where the reading stops increasing, the reading will not change until the ball is withdrawn to that limit. Once it passes that limit, the reading will decrease in magnitude, till it goes back to zero, or where it starts. The third case is more interesting, for once the ball touches the pail, the ball is perfectly discharged. And it matters not if the ball is then withdrawn from or enters the pail. The electrometer is then not found to react to any change of the position of the ball. Faraday therefore concludes, when touching the pail, the ball must have communicated its charge entirely to the pail, and that charge is from then on kept in the pail.

But a conclusion much more important is drawn by Faraday from these phenomena observed. Since, once that limit is passed, there is no difference in reading between if the ball touches the pail or not, one can reason that the charge induced on the outside of the pail is equal to the charge carried by the ball. For only the static electrical inductive action takes place between the ball and the pail when the ball is not touching the pail, and when the ball touches the pail, it is perfectly discharged and communicates its charge to the pail. One can thereby readily grant that any change in the reading between when the ball passes the limit but does not touch the pail and after the ball touches the pail has to be due to a difference between the power of induction by the ball on the pail and the power of charge communicated in its entirety from the ball to the pail. Therefore, if there is no change in the reading, the power of induction of the carrier ball on the pail must be equal to that power of the charge communicated to the pail. Since the ball is perfectly discharged, the charge initially carried by the ball must be equal to the charge communicated to the pail. Therefore, Faraday concludes, “the electricity induced by C [the ball] and the electricity in C are accurately equal in amount and power”. That is, the charge carried by the ball is equal to the charge it communicates to the pail, which is again equal to the effect initially induced by the ball. Hence, the electrical power carried by the ball is equal to its inductive power on the pail.

There is one more thing worth noting here. In this experiment, Faraday is not primarily occupied by the inner mechanism of electrical induction or conduction. He is only directly interested in general principles. That is why he does not try to explain why the electrometer should have the same kind of charge, i.e. positive or negative, as that which is carried by the ball. Also, he does not examine what might be potentially different between the inside and the outside of the pail. It could be that he presupposes Phillips to know the inner mechanism of induction and conduction in this particular set-up. Nonetheless, his silence on this matter expresses where his more immediate interest lies. To understand this experiment fully, one merely needs to know that in general, whatever happens to the electrometer must be due to the action of the carrier, since the carrier ball is the only electrified object in the whole set-up. One also knows that if the carrier does not touch the pail, the action is inductive, and if it touches, the action is conductive. And if the effects caused by the two actions are the same, effect being equal to its cause, their causes must by this reasoning be equal, i.e. the power of induction is equal to the electrical power.

Next, Faraday makes a move that is even more interesting. He modifies the experiment set-up into a Russian doll. Instead of one pail, he devises multiple pails of varying sizes containing one another. Between two pails, there can be insulation, or not. If with insulation, one pail only affects another pail through induction; if without, they conjointly represent one singular pail. The carrier, again, enters the innermost pail, and touches it, or not, and one observes any effect on the electrometer connected to the outside of the outermost pail. All results remain the same as in the first experiment: there is no change in the effect on the electrometer whether the carrier touches the pail or not, once it passes the limit. This modification of the experiment, however, makes explicit another principle that is not expressed in the earlier experiment. That is, distance does not affect the exertion of the inductive power of the carrier. However far the induced body is from the inducing body, the inducing power seems to not have dispersed one bit across the distance. This conclusion, nevertheless, needs to be qualified. For we should expect everything to be charged all the time if this principle were unconditionally true, as one inducing body should be able to induce equal electricity in another body, and this induced body by its induced electricity should again induce equal electricity in another body, in infinitum. There then should remain nothing uncharged, and we should not need to bring any conductor near the carrier in order to get an induced charge in it, which is obviously false and absurd.

Though Faraday does not answer this paradox in this letter per se, he does offer his explanation in the eleventh series of his researches. In entries 1295. and 1296. of this series, Faraday explains, “induction requires no sensible thickness in the conductors which may be used to limit its extent”, while “with regard to the dielectrics or insulating media, matters are very different. Their thickness has an immediate and important influence on the degree of induction... amongst solid bodies, and between them and gases, there are differences which prove the existence of specific inductive capacities, these differences being in some cases very great”. Since all the pails are metallic conductors, and the dielectric media in between them are not great in amount or strength, the loss of the power of induction in transmission is negligible in this experiment. The correct formulation of the principle, therefore, is that distance does not affect the the inducing action across a contiguous conductive medium. However, this principle, important by itself, is not Faraday’s primary focus in this letter, the subject of which is the equality between inductive power and electrical power of the body. What is more relevant to his principal interest in this modification of the experiment, I believe, is the mutual transformation between an inducing agent and a conducting agent. One sees here that across the distance, one pail can be transformed from being the inducing agent, insulated from the next pail, to being the conducting agent, transmitting its charge to the next pail after it is connected to the next pail. This operation can be repeated as many times as there are pails, five times if there are five pails, seven times if there are seven, etc. In one experiment, therefore, one sees the principle continually substantiated without fail as many times as one wishes. This conveniently establishes the universality of the principle.

Two other additions are made to the initial conception of the principle, which states the inductive power of a body is equal to the electrical power carried by the same body. One is that, the distribution of the electricity, or inductive power, throughout the body does not affect the equality between inductive and electrical power. This time, Faraday introduces multiple carriers which presumably carry different charges and are placed at different positions. In this demonstration, if one of the carriers is discharged to the pail and then withdrawn, while other carriers remain inside the pail, no change is shown in the effect on the electrometer.

Before we embark on an analysis of this experiment, it is not amiss to clarify first how Faraday conceives of cause and effect. Cause is a power that creates an effect. But only effect is observable. Effect is the measure and expression of cause. The power in an electrified body causes a related effect that in turn allows us to measure the magnitude of this power. The effect in this experiment is the reading on the electrometer. But this effect can be caused in two ways, through induction or conduction. If through induction, the effect expresses an inductive power of the carrier. If through conduction, a power in the carrier is transmitted to the electrometer. I call this power electrical power. Both powers are measured by the effect on electrometer. But the carrier itself is supposed to carry a charge that also expresses these powers. One is therefore justified to say that the charge in the carrier is an expression of its power, or an expression of the cause of the effect on the electrometer, which charge is equal to the charge in the electrometer reading.

Now, Faraday claims that these carriers bring the same effect to the electrometer as if there is only one carrier charged uniformly. This equality in effectiveness between multiple differently charged carriers and one uniformly charged carrier is evident from the fact that the effect on the electrometer is brought about only by the total amount of power. There is observed no difference in the induced effect on the electrometer to have the inductive powers distributed unequally so long as the total inductive power is maintained. That is, by simply moving these carriers around in the vessel, or discharging them among themselves, as long as one has no reason to assume the total inductive power of these carriers in the vessel has changed, the induced effect is shown to remain the same. So is the induced effect caused by multiple carriers believed to be the same as that which is caused by a carrier uniformly charged, which has the same total amount of inductive power. And for all these carriers, the principle of equality between inductive power and electrical power holds throughout, for the discharge of any number of them to the pail does not change the effect on the electrometer. Therefore, each carrier’s inductive power undischarged is equal to its electrical power discharged, and the total amount of inductive power of all carriers undischarged added together is equal to the total amount of electrical power of all carriers discharged added together, both expressed by the total charge initially carried by the carriers added together. Multiple carriers with unequal inductive powers do not differ in effect from a carrier that has the same total inductive power unequally distributed, which again does not differ in effect from a carrier that has the same total power equally distributed. And since electrical power is equal to inductive power throughout, the same holds for electrical power, too. Since charge measures power, multiple carriers charged differently equal in effect, no matter this effect is caused through induction or conduction, one carrier uniformly charged of the same amount. A corollary follows from this. Since multiple carriers can be conceived as different portions of one singular carrier, and conversely, different portions of the same carrier can be considered as altogether different bodies, we are here provided with a model for partial discharge or imperfect discharge. Any partial discharge of a body can be considered as a perfect discharge of one of its portions. Therefore, any amount of inductive power undischarged can be transformed into an equal amount of electrical power discharged, regardless if the discharge on the whole is perfect or not. In any discharge, partial or not, the sum of inductive power from the yet undischarged plus the electrical power transmitted from the already discharged, therefore, should always be conserved.

The other addition is that, whatever medium is held in the pail into which the carrier is introduced, and “whatever other means be taken to vary the forces”, before and after discharge, there is no difference in the effect on the electrometer. Therefore, the inductive power always equals the electrical power, even when the shown effect apparently does not equal the cause. Yet this is mysterious. For Faraday is not saying that the difference in the readings is negligible, but that “the amount of action is precisely the same”, even when dielectric is employed to separate the carrier from the pail. How can the inductive power of the carrier, weakened by the dielectric between it and the pail, be equal to its power of electricity, which is communicated to the pail without loss? I believe this is a misuse of language on Faraday’s part, since he is very clear in 1303. that “with the same constraining force [induction] takes place the more easily, according as the extent of dielectric through which it is exerted is lessened... so it would seem to follow that the fewer there are of these intervening particles opposing their tendency to the assumption of the new state, the greater degree of change will they suffer, i.e., the higher will be the condition they assume, and the larger the amount of inductive action exerted through them”. However, a more generous reading might be that here Faraday is only saying there is no positive evidence found in the experiment against his theory.

What is his theory, and how do these experiments prove it? We are now ready to answer these questions. First, we know that the various versions of the ice-pail experiment prove nothing other than the principle that the inductive power of a body is equal to the electrical power it carries. The first modification of this experiment with multiple pails expresses in one single experiment the universality of this principle. The second modification not only emphasizes the equality is between the total amount of inductive power and the total amount of electrical power, but also demonstrates how a partial discharge is just like a perfect discharge, and provides us with a more accurate conception of the conservation of total power, which is a conservation of the sum of inductive power undischarged and electrical power discharged. The third modification I conceive to be his emphasis on the strength of the observational evidence supporting the truth of this principle, that no counter-evidence has yet been observed. Though even if an inequality is in fact noticed, it may still be explained by the weakening effect exerted on the inductive action by the dielectric medium, provided that the induced effect is lesser than the communicated effect.

How does this principle help Faraday? How does it support his view and theory of induction? More than anything, this principle establishes an identity between the two most prominent phenomena of electricity, i.e. induction and conduction, and maintains that any amount of inductive power can be transformed into an equal amount of electricity discharged. From a quantitative equality thus drawn, Faraday is thereby justified to make a qualitative inference: induction and conduction might share a common root, and be two manifestations of the same thing. This is his ambition from the start when he suggests that all electrical phenomena can perhaps be reduced to induction. Moreover, since conduction relies upon contiguous particles that transmit electricity, this equality between induction and conduction is circumstantial evidence that induction, being essentially of the same kind, should not be totally independent of the contiguity of particles, thus supporting his particle theory of induction. One also now understands more fully why Faraday remains silent about the inner mechanism of induction, for this is exactly where the controversy lies, where he needs to prove his own theory of the subject, which theory is not something he can take for granted and assume others to have accepted.