Gui Ruiyan

Nikolai Lobachevsky · 尼古拉·罗巴切夫斯基
Non-Euclidean geometry · 非欧几何

Axiomatics of Space

Paper / 论文

The greatest tension I personally experience in my encounters with the Lobachevskian space is that between intuition and reason. By intuition, I mean that capacity to visualize through my intellectual perception, and by reason, I mean the capacity to deduce from a given set of axioms. There are some manifestations of this tension. For instance, though it is clearly stated by Lobachevsky that both parallels and ultra-parallels in the Lobachevskian plane are straight lines, I could not resist the temptation to often depict them as curves. I also encounter this problem representing finite straight lines in this new geometry, though much less frequently. This brings me to question what precisely is meant by ‘straightness.’ This question has two parts. First, if we say great circles on the sphere are like straight lines in the Euclidean space because they fulfill a number of conditions laid out on page 47 of the manual, can we determine what are the conditions those Lobachevskian straight lines fulfill? What further complicates the problem is that we start doing this geometry assuming we already have the straight lines, and we only modify the properties of the space to harmonize with these assumed straight lines. Therefore, we need to first determine what are the properties of the Lobachevskian space, and then determine what kind of lines in this space can properly be called straight. Second, to the more philosophical side, through this investigation, hopefully we can arrive at a more rigorous determination of our concept of ‘straightness.’

What amazes me is that, despite the fact we can always tweak the logical axioms and derive a logically self-consistent system that somehow transcends our intuition, geometry has not fully lost its intuitiveness. Rather, visualization remains basic to our geometrical understanding regardless of the symbolic or formal character modern mathematics has assumed.