Gui Ruiyan

Miscellaneous · 杂记
Measurement · 测量

Is There a Measure on Earth?

Paper / 论文 · Date from document metadata / 日期据原稿文件信息 · Editorial title / 本版编拟标题

When Hölderlin asks in one of his poems “is there a measure on earth?” he formulates, with his peculiar clairvoyance and insight, one of the most difficult questions of all times; however, his definitive answer to that question, namely a diametrical “there is none”, is hardly satisfying. But in order to see the full scope of this question, we have to understand what lies behind this poetical formulation. In a way, Hölderlin is opposing the earthly realm with the heavenly divine, so that for him, it becomes a problem how the murkiness and darkness of earth can give birth to a measure. This conception, of course, is already founded upon a consequential presupposition: that a measure has to bring clarity to the things measured, thus making them more intelligible than they were.

Is this belief really justified? Is there any alternative understanding of measure other than a form of clarification? Does measurement necessarily clear things up for us? To examine these questions, it is inevitable that we look into our experience, and try to measure up our notion of measure against the rule of the world.

Let’s take the measuring of length as an example. When a length is measured, there are always two things involved: the measuring and the measured. A length does not measure itself, thus it always requires an other to put it into a comparison. By this very fact, are we tempted to agree with Socrates’ Protagoras, that everything is for an other? Not yet; since measuring does not stop at the putting together of two things, but rather they have to reach a certain agreement. When we measure a certain length, we do not merely put the length beside the ruler. We count up the units that would match the cutting edge of that length, where the length abruptly stops, and we announce that number of units to be of “the same” of that length measured. By this token, the two parties will ultimately be unified into one same thing. It would be very ridiculous if we say, in the end, that “one meter” and a “one-meter-long length” to be of different lengths. Nevertheless, it results in great confusion when the doubling of things suddenly dissolves into a unification. This confusion is most poignant when we think how the unity is itself different from any of those two things being compared. Take the internationally approved “meter” as an example, which is really just a stick in Paris. If we think about that meter stick being shortened over time, we are still capable of judging it to fall short of the true “meter” that unifies those different sticks. Then, is what we call meter that stick, or that ghostly figure of the “one true meter” we somehow have a sense of?

It seems like a specter is conjured up every time a measure is taken. Separate things suddenly seem to be conjoined in a definite relationship. Two questions then ensue. First, how do we characterize that relationship? Second, how do we understand this “conjuring up”?

The first characterization we offer of this relationship is that of a unity. This relationship has to express a sameness, that one thing is as another. But that is not the whole story. As the two things are measured against each other, they cannot become one, otherwise it will be a self-measure, which is no measure at all. Thus, a unification in this sense always incorporates its counter-moment, that of dispersion, though a rather limited dispersion that is restricted by the whole. The word that is commonly assigned to such a relationship is “harmony”.

Dispersion happens when things come to be different, and unification the reverse; but this is already assuming that the two moments are two counter-movements. When things separate, they become different, whereas when things gather, they become the same. The question, nevertheless, becomes pressing: when we measure things up, do we really see a double movement? This is also related to the other question we put forth a while ago: what is the nature of the “conjuring up”? is this a mere result of that double movement?

But there is not always movement; in fact, in most of the cases where a measurement is taken, things are quite at rest. I do need to multiply the ruler for many times if I need to measure a very long line, and multiplying certainly involves motion on my part. But in the end, things are quite at peace lying alongside each other; we do not necessarily observe a movement of being dispersed and being gathered at the same time, or even at different times, during the course of measurement. It is not the case that the ruler and the body measured suddenly take flight and suddenly join together like a pair of magnets.

Even if we take a case in which movement seems to be importantly involved, like the measuring of time, the process of measuring might take place in a gradual unfolding of one movement matching up with another, but the match itself, the fact that one slice of time measures another slice does not require the two slices themselves to be in movements. Not only does it not require, it actively rejects the idea of movement. Let us assume that an object in constant movement is measured, then the very instant after that measure is taken the object will be moving out of that measure, if it is moving with respect to what is measured. In that sense, it is impossible for a moving thing to be measured; any measure taken is between two things at rest, or two things transformed into a state of rest. Like when I measure the distance over which the moving ball traverses, I have to wait till it is at rest to take that measure successfully.

But is not the “conjuring up” a legitimate sense expressed by the measuring in our common experience? Do we not always share the feeling, that something new pops up when two things are put together, that they suddenly seem to say something as one, and become a new expression?

So, what is this monstrosity, this mixture of movements at rest? If the two things in the course of being measured are at total rest, how do they “bring about” a measure? But perhaps this is not too unfamiliar. When we have a force and a counter-force being applied to a body, ofttimes we find the body at rest; when that tendency to change is countered by another tendency, inactivity is the result. Then, are we tempted to say, that when two things are measured, they are always in some kind of equilibrium? This seems plausible, if we totally disregard the difference between movement and force. What happens in measurement is not merely that the bodies have a tendency to disperse or unify; no, the dispersion and unification are carried out and effectively actualized. The two parties in being measured have to persistently be separate and joined, as we have seen above, and this is not the same as to hold in reserve a potency that only waits to be actualized in future. The stasis is the confluence of movements.

Shall we say, then, the two movements in opposing merely “cancel each other out”? The problem, however, remains. How is it possible to cancel something that is required to happen, is always happening, and always has happened? It should be noted, that, it is prior to the actual measurement taking place that the two things should be posited against each other in a harmony; this harmony lays the very foundation of making any measurement possible in the first place. Without the two things being different, a measurement has no reason to exist; yet without their being the same, a measurement cannot be conclusive. Then, in what way can the two movements cancel each other out, yet preserve that double effect?

Let us think of a different example. The sun traverses; she follows a certain route, and if she ever oversteps too much, disasters like famine will ensue. But she does constantly overstep, which gives forth the seasons. Yet, there is always that limit which she holds dear. She gives light and warmth, which brings forth life, harvest, and joy. In this sense, she brings forth all that which has value to us. But she sometimes goes out of bounds; that is what we call night. The division of day and night gives us the most natural and original unit of time. Being and non-being reflect each other as they shine and darken, this primary experience constitutes all of that what time means. Time, originally, is given by the sun; time, thus, is given by a giving-forth. And the sun rules, perhaps in her own time, everything on earth, according to her own measure of traversing, thus giving measure to all things, as she also gives time.

Let us think back to what happens in a measurement. The things measuring and being measured overflow into its other, but does not overstep the limit. A measure is given in that very instant of putting things together; something new is thereby conjured up. But it is conjured up outside of time; by this original measuring, a time is given. The things spill and disperse, as if were about to be lost and destroyed in that darkest of nights; but are rescued at the limit, as if by an un-thinged receptacle. They move, but not really; this is the power of time. It is only in time, that you can have the same thing enduring, aging, and dying, but holding onto itself and striving. The fact that we do not seem to notice any change or movement when two things are lying alongside each other perhaps has to do with our habitual exclusion of time or taking account of perceiving in time in science; in its most radical sense, taking rest also happens in a time. Thus, when bodies are at rest when being measured, they are still moving in time; and this temporal movement is the double bind described above. Time is the rhythm via which things show themselves; in that sense, time is measure.

But, does it not mean that, if measure and time were the same, measurement is necessarily temporal? In a sense, yes; but that giving of measure itself originates outside time, like the sun gives time forth to earth. Measuring is thus a breed of both the earthly and the divine; it seems, ultimately, that Protagoras is right in calling man as the measure of all things, since what is man except that strange breed of the earthly and the divine?

Hölderlin is absolutely right in asking that question “is there a measure on earth?”, but his answer ignores the fact that it is only on earth that a measure can be established, whereas with the divine there is no need of a measure at all. And, finally, if we interpret the intelligible as something so elevated as to not connect to earth, which only seems to those to taint their godlike all-seeing view, then we could say that measurement is not intended for that kind of clarification, hence is not intelligible. But, if we stick to the more undercurrent meaning of intelligible as that of the “idea(seen)”, as that which receives sunlight on earth and reflects it in an articulation with all other beings together, then it is most intelligible. Or, to put it even more radically, it is the intelligible itself. Science, if it does not view itself as a radical poetical practice, will lose eventually its supreme power of clarification, through ossifying its own perspective and making every object it touches, like the Midas touch, into a static, not-giving-forth fossil. When nature stands as an ungenerous corpse and stops giving herself forth, what more could a natural science do? Will it, perhaps, assert itself as that new voracious tyrant, to impose measures of his own and claim those to be the general principles of nature......?