Gui Ruiyan

Isaac Newton · 艾萨克·牛顿
Principia · 自然哲学的数学原理

An Outline for Division of the First 17 Propositions in Newton’s Principia

Paper / 论文

To trace the development of Newton’s argument throughout the first 17 propositions from his Principia, it would be necessary to first clarify his overall objectives. There are two objectives, one general, the other specific. Newton’s general objective is to provide a method for producing adequate mathematical descriptions of centripetal force under given circumstances. His specific objective is to determine what mathematical descriptions fit the most the motions of bodies in our perceivable cosmic system. The first 17 propositions achieve the general objective and lay the foundation for the specific one.

I divide these 17 propositions into four groups. The first 3 propositions form the first group. Proposition 4 is its own group. I assign the third group to proposition 5 up till proposition 13. Finally, the remaining 3 propositions I make into the last group. I will show my reasoning by explaining roughly the function each proposition serves in common with other propositions belonging to the same group.

Proposition 1 provides the foundation for all later reasonings. Here Newton establishes the most general behavior of any moving body suffering from a centripetal force, that is, the moving body describes around the center equal areas by equal times. In other words, the proposition maintains that the area a body describes orbiting a center, with changing or unchanging centripetal force, is always proportionate to the time through which it travels. Proposition 2 proves the converse, thus ensconcing this established pattern into the essence of centripetal force. From now on, we can safely deduce the presence of centripetal force from this pattern of the uniform description of areas, and vice versa. Proposition 3 is Newton’s effort to relate the generality of the first two propositions to his more specific objective. In proposition 3, he puts his mathematical construct back into the physical universe. The center of force in this proposition is no longer disembodied. Moreover, bodies are not enclosed in one singular system of orbits, but are themselves affected by external forces. The conclusion does not vary from previous propositions, provided that the bodies in the selected system all suffer from the same external force. The first three propositions, therefore, give us both the most general sign to identify centripetal force and the essential pattern centripetal force produces, i.e. the uniform description of areas.

Proposition 4 tells us, given several bodies orbiting the same center in a similar way (describing similar shapes), their motions and the forces they suffer have to each other certain quantitative relationships. These relationships are of a general character, for they are all formulated through hypotheticals: if the velocity is as some power of the radius, then the centripetal force should be as another determinate power of the radius, and the periodic time yet another power of the radius. This gives us a general guide for later usage, for we know once we get one relationship determined we can easily derive all the other ones.

Now as proposition 5 gives us a way to fix the center when velocity is given, proposition 6 gives us a formula to generate laws of centripetal force when the center is given. I put proposition 5 into the same group as proposition 6 for I believe both give us “methods” to find our interested objects, the center of force in the former instance, the law of centripetal force in the latter, though proposition 6 is more continuously used throughout the course of Newton’s argument. From the next proposition up to proposition 13 are applications of proposition 6. For what Newton does in these propositions is simply to employ the same geometrical construct (the centripetal force “solid”) he has devised in proposition 6 to deduce the laws of centripetal force for different figures with their centers of force at different positions.

Now since the celestial bodies in our solar system move in conic sections, the last few propositions in the third group have already pointed to Newton’s specific objective. And moving forward, through the final group of propositions, Newton is able to not only deduce the law of centripetal force for any conic section with its center of force at its focus, but also to determine the exact shape of the orbit with a given velocity, its center determinable based on proposition 5, so long as some section of the orbit is given together with the velocity. By these final propositions, Newton has laid the foundation for understanding how the celestial bodies acquainted to us (in the solar system) behave, thus making apparent the specific objective, which he is going to further substantiate in Book III.