Gui Ruiyan

Plato · 柏拉图
Apology, Crito · 申辩 · 克里托

Undated 未注日期

Apology, Crito — Reading notes

Reflections · Apple Notes

Revised 14 November 2021

In this note / 篇目

Apology, Crito

17b deed vs speech

19a dear to the god, law must be obeyed

20e a human wisdom, instead of an over-human one; Delphic Apollo as witness

21a what is the motivation to consult oracle about who is wiser? If not knowing oneself to be wise?

21c dare to challenge god; yet is god’s Oracle challengeable somehow? Herodotus?

22b who would even ask a poet word by word what he meant......but makes sense to say poets are inspired but not wise

22e Socrates’ own opinion is taken the same as god’s; and wisdom is not measured only in part, but rather as a whole

23b one probable interpretation; and he serves god by his very dedication to the interpretation

24b “as though these were other accusers”; so actually came from the prior prejudices

28d defend himself with resort to poetry; and are there two Achilles, one fearless of death, one hates it in hades? And is he revising it a bit?

29c an intriguing statement: either not bring in at all, or kill him to the end

30c does not care the speech harmful or not; only sticks to the content of educating the soul

31b reason and philosophy starts with an unreasonable urge

31e opposition to politics; survive the politics

32a what you honor, deeds

33c philosophy for pleasure

37b refute 36b’s proposal

37e isn’t this contradicting the previous claim that no relatives are prosecuting him?

38c Socrates here is not accusing Athens; he doesn’t claim himself to be a wise man; he’s just pointing out the consequence as a prophet

40b the daimonic voice

40e sleep; all time but one night

41e the reason of the blame is stated

44c just men will believe in the tale