Gui Ruiyan

Plato · 柏拉图
Parmenides · 巴门尼德

Undated 未注日期

Parmenides — Reading notes

Reflections · Apple Notes

Revised 16 January 2022

In this note / 篇目

Parmenides

126c a circumspect remembrance; leave philosophy to ride horses

127a hesitation, a difficult task

127b a festival of celebration and rites

127d reading of a treatise not a dialogue to start; thirty tyrants, Aristoteles who is the main interlocutor later

128e time and accidents on philosophy

130a can ideas be intermixed like visible things?

130e still young; a parallel to Zeno’s youth work; hair mud dirt etc is despised; is Socrates educated to be a philosopher in this dialogue?

131d smaller than large, hence small; smaller than equal, hence unequal; smaller than small, hence small is large

132b infinite regress of ideas

132c being and thinking; Socrates argues that thinking can proffer the ever same oneness and seems to be outside the problem caused by being, but Parmenides argues that thinking and being are held together and hence have to be inextricable in the same problematic

132d since the form and the things resembling the form are like to each other in reverse directions, so their likeness has to be expressed by another form

133e mastership and slavery each relative to the other to be definable; a negative relationship of ideas. But this ideal plane is separate from the master-slave reality relation

134e non-relation of divine and human

135c power of thought

135e wander among things of rational account

136c experiment all hypotheses

138a is unity a point?

139c being different from different thing implies to be compared with something different, then is to be compared with something else; then not in itself different; so not different

141a a dimension outside time; a thing is becoming older means that it’s not definitively different than itself, so is not definitively older, so is also younger than itself; also equal to itself

142a be to or of nothing? Self contradiction

142c being and unity

142d when is being said to be one? Or does he mean everything in itself is one? Or does he mean a particular being of unity is one? But in any case being and unity as different things are gathered into one whole.

144a an ideational origin of numbers

Second deduction a reverse of the first; antinomy

Is Socrates in his first or second sailing at this time? He says it’s only safe to say one is big because of bigness; but does he not see how problematic bigness is?

152a being and time; compared to the first exposition in first deduction, is added the dimension of being in the present; since what becomes cannot overstep the now, it always is what it was becoming. And this exposition is somehow different but not contrary to the first.

154c being precedes becoming or otherwise?

156e the instant as a time other than time

157d a whole is different from a plurality in the sense that a plurality is not one and are not ones, and in that sense a part cannot be determined

160d what is not is something different and can be known; knowledge of what is not

A thing requires not-being to be, and being to not be

The problem of beginnings