Plato · 柏拉图
Parmenides · 巴门尼德
Undated 未注日期
Parmenides — Reading notes
Reflections · Apple Notes
Revised 16 January 2022
In this note / 篇目
Parmenides
126c a circumspect remembrance; leave philosophy to ride horses
127a hesitation, a difficult task
127b a festival of celebration and rites
127d reading of a treatise not a dialogue to start; thirty tyrants, Aristoteles who is the main interlocutor later
128e time and accidents on philosophy
130a can ideas be intermixed like visible things?
130e still young; a parallel to Zeno’s youth work; hair mud dirt etc is despised; is Socrates educated to be a philosopher in this dialogue?
131d smaller than large, hence small; smaller than equal, hence unequal; smaller than small, hence small is large
132b infinite regress of ideas
132c being and thinking; Socrates argues that thinking can proffer the ever same oneness and seems to be outside the problem caused by being, but Parmenides argues that thinking and being are held together and hence have to be inextricable in the same problematic
132d since the form and the things resembling the form are like to each other in reverse directions, so their likeness has to be expressed by another form
133e mastership and slavery each relative to the other to be definable; a negative relationship of ideas. But this ideal plane is separate from the master-slave reality relation
134e non-relation of divine and human
135c power of thought
135e wander among things of rational account
136c experiment all hypotheses
138a is unity a point?
139c being different from different thing implies to be compared with something different, then is to be compared with something else; then not in itself different; so not different
141a a dimension outside time; a thing is becoming older means that it’s not definitively different than itself, so is not definitively older, so is also younger than itself; also equal to itself
142a be to or of nothing? Self contradiction
142c being and unity
142d when is being said to be one? Or does he mean everything in itself is one? Or does he mean a particular being of unity is one? But in any case being and unity as different things are gathered into one whole.
144a an ideational origin of numbers
Second deduction a reverse of the first; antinomy
Is Socrates in his first or second sailing at this time? He says it’s only safe to say one is big because of bigness; but does he not see how problematic bigness is?
152a being and time; compared to the first exposition in first deduction, is added the dimension of being in the present; since what becomes cannot overstep the now, it always is what it was becoming. And this exposition is somehow different but not contrary to the first.
154c being precedes becoming or otherwise?
156e the instant as a time other than time
157d a whole is different from a plurality in the sense that a plurality is not one and are not ones, and in that sense a part cannot be determined
160d what is not is something different and can be known; knowledge of what is not
A thing requires not-being to be, and being to not be
The problem of beginnings
本文由 AI 从英文原文翻译。请以原文为准。
In this note / 篇目
巴门尼德
126c 审慎的回忆;放下哲学去骑马
127a 犹豫;一项困难的任务
127b 庆典与仪式的节日
127d 以诵读一篇论著而非对话开场;三十僭主中的阿里斯托泰勒斯,后来成为主要对话者
128e 时间与偶然事件对哲学的作用
130a 理念能像可见事物那样混合吗?
130e 还年轻;与芝诺的早年著作相呼应;头发、泥土、污物等受到鄙视;苏格拉底是否在这个对话中被教育成哲学家?
131d 比大更小,因此是小;比相等更小,因此不相等;比小更小,因此小是大的
132b 理念的无限回退
132c 在与思;苏格拉底认为思可以提供永远相同的一性,似乎由此置身于在所引发的问题之外;但巴门尼德认为思与在被维系在一起,因此必然不可分离地处于同一个问题域中
132d 既然形式与相似于形式的事物在相反方向上彼此相似,那么它们的相似性就必须由另一个形式表达
133e 主人身份与奴隶身份各自相对于另一者才可定义;理念之间的一种否定关系。但这一理念平面与现实的主奴关系是分离的
134e 神与人的非关系
135c 思的力量
135e 在可由理性论说的事物间漫游
136c 试验所有假设
138a 一性是一个点吗?
139c 与不同的事物不同,意味着要与某个不同的东西相比,也就是与某个他物相比;因此并非自在地不同,所以并不不同
141a 时间之外的维度;一个东西正在变老,意味着它尚未确定地不同于自身,因此尚未确定地更老,所以也比自身更年轻;也与自身同龄
142a 对于无物,或属于无物而在?自相矛盾
142c 在与一性
142d 何时可以说在是一?还是他意谓任何东西在自身中都是一?或是说一性的某个特殊存在是一?但无论如何,在与一性作为不同的事物被聚集为一个整体。
144a 数的理念起源
第二次推演是第一次的颠倒;二律背反
此时的苏格拉底是在第一次还是第二次航行中?他说,只有说某物因大本身而大才是稳妥的;但他没看到大本身有多成问题吗?
152a 在与时间;相比第一次推演中的最初阐述,这里增加了在当下存在的维度;由于生成之物不能越过现在,它总已经是它正在变成的东西。这一阐述与第一次有所不同,却不相反。
154c 在先于生成,还是相反?
156e 瞬间是不同于时间的时间
157d 整体不同于杂多,因为杂多不是一,也不是诸一;在这个意义上,一个部分无法被确定
160d 不在者是某个不同的东西,并且可以被认识;对不在者的知识
一个东西要在,就需要不在;要不在,就需要在
开端的问题