Gui Ruiyan

Plato · 柏拉图
Phaedo · 斐多

Undated 未注日期

Phaedo — Reading notes

Reflections · Apple Notes

Revised 12 February 2024

In this note / 篇目

I

57a a report and recollection

58a resounds with Socrates’ prophecy

58d socrates death pleasure

60b funny to his wife; woman

60c pain and pleasure follow one another; 60d Socrates makes poetry! And after he’s in prison

61d change the posture now into sitting

Argument: philosopher should be ready to die, but cannot kill himself because he’s god’s possession
Counter argument: being ready to die is to accept getting away from the good master, which is unreasonable
Conclusion: have to prove in death there is more good

64a philosophy is devoted to dying and being dead

66b philosopher won over to *opinion
*
66e “behold” “desire” “lovers”

67c separation does not entail purification; life’s purpose is to purify and prepare

69b thoughtfulness as a coin; inappropriate metaphor

71a only becoming and coming to be but not being?

73a from becoming to being

74a truth originates from untruth

78a incantations

79c but it’s also mentioned that the visible things would be as indexes for invisible things; if seeing visible things only makes the soul dizzy, then how is recollection possible? And if soul is self-same, how is the turning movement possible in republic?

81b it is possible for a soul to be contaminated; “shadowy”

82c man to become gods

83c suffering is untruth; can there be pleasure and pain unrelated to the body?

II

84c entranced

85a swan song; inferior in prophecy: but his prophecy seems to be accurate

86 counter argument: soul is a measuring and tuning; is this a different account than before? This tuning is vulnerable

87 counter argument: soul wears out bodies but is still mortal

88c beyond trust; distrust even what’s to follow

89d hatred

90a in between; 90c arguments are not characterized as wicked and good, or does he mean arguments have no in-between? So there’s mixed being & non-being, contributing to untruth and flux?

91a it’s not the fault of argument but the fault of man

Tuning argument: 1. Soul is a tuning
2. Soul has virtue and vice, so tuning is itself tuned differently; soul within a soul
3. But a tuning tuned differently will make a tuning more or less of a tuning
4. So virtue and vice will make a soul more or less of a soul
5. But a soul cannot be more or less of a soul but needs to be equal
6. And a tuning that is untuned is itself untuned, hence not a tuning
7. So a soul that partakes of vice is not a soul; which is untrue, since a soul can partake of vice

96a pause; my own experience: inquiry into nature

97c mind orders the world, it must order it in the best way

99b necessary condition vs efficient cause

99e in Republic look at the sun in its own realm; but also said it was perhaps inappropriate analogy; a greater problem is whether the second sailing still concerns with the “best”?

100c cause being participation?

101b if big thing were to be big by something small, then being and nonbeing are mixed

102b “gets its name”

103c contrary vs contrary things; a thing, or matter, can undergo change from one to its contrary, but contraries themselves won’t become or co-present

103e something has essence that does not permit certain contraries to be co-present

105c from “The Hot” to hotness to fire

106d the undying soul is imperishable; what is the difference between being undying and being imperishable? One being its content the other being its form?

110a Earth, intelligent realm brought into physical connection

110c the transcending realm is more vivid in color

114d noble risk; incantations