Gui Ruiyan

Plato · 柏拉图
Republic · 理想国

Undated 未注日期

Republic — Reading notes

Reflections · Apple Notes

Revised 23 July 2022

In this note / 篇目

1

376 philosopher=being friendly to things known(familiar?) and hostile to things unknown? A philosopher should know who are enemies and who are friends, not those who one is ignorant of automatically turns into an enemy. It’s not love of learning, but love of the learned, or love of the familiar.

A city made up of arts; but there’s no performing the action for its own sake

378b injustice creeps in secretly

378a two standards: truth and fineness(good disposition?)

378d ironic, since Socrates is educating with a ton of hidden senses

380b justice linked to the divine

381a problematic in two senses: good things like friendship and love are always changing; time itself is the most eternal thing, then is time the best? Counter examples: Aristotle, Odysseus

380c the law has to acquire a vote but not necessary

381e mother role, family, which is previously implicated in kinship laws

382e what about lying for pleasure? Or is it necessary to do things for their usefulness?

382b can truth be harmful?

386a friendship is mentioned

386c neither true nor beneficial

387e good for something else; and self-sufficiency is incompatible with city

389b “your argument“

392c glaucon’s original argument banned; but how does that come about?

395c imitation = a taste of being; is Plato imitating? Is Plato talking in this way, imitating Socrates the good man, and narrating others?

399e purged of luxuries; reasons for having an army undermined

401a if the good disposition precedes good harmonies, then what use is imitation for the youth?

403c music and love; Gymnastics, where’s medicine? Seems pastry and gymnastics are in oppositions

403e but isn’t Socrates and glaucon doing the guard?

404d reminded of the promised feast

405b medicine and judge is base

413b the gradual encroachment of the tragic

414d the mother in 381 is banished

415a the unnatural incestuous relationships

416c not sure of efficacy of education

2

430c courage is educated and lawful; a qualification as political courage

432c comedy dramatization

435d a longer and harder road taken

437a an assumption that opposites are only present in different parts

442b noble lie in the city; noble lie in the soul? But a noble lie in the soul is the true lie, that’s not wanted by anyone

443c dream and divine; true justice and phantom of justice

445a unnoticed by men and gods; but noticed by oneself

449c Eros, 450b a lot of trouble——>soul

452c not minding their business

458e erotic necessities

460c khora, chance is a pretense

461e still more incestuous!!!

462a, suspicious argument; 462b now shift to the pains and pleasures

464e nothing private but the body, an irreducible element; 465a if can truly be shared pleasures and pains, then why body self-defense?

470d again one vs other

473e paradox of philosopher-King

474d Love

475e True vs likenesses

476c Fairness as a gateway

477c why is it necessary to make the distinction? What distinction?

480a the conclusion can be drawn that lover of fair sights don’t love? Lovers of sounds omitted.

497c here adamentius is trapping Socrates: if philosopher is required to rule for the regime to be possible, then how should the philosopher rule if his rule again requires the ideal city?

3

508a a yoke, or an 508b excess?

509c what’s ridiculous about it?

509d divided line, the lower part of intelligible equals upper part of the visible

511c arts are opposed to dialectic

511d intellection and visibility are both affections of the soul; and the four participate, so not different objects; truth vs clarity

514a an image is made to clarify the line which should have surpassed images

515d released from bonds by nature

515e negativity as familiarity

516b impossible! You would be blinded!

516c in a certain way the cause: so fire is analogous to the sun?

517b a Self-Division of the sun into source of the visible realm and the source of the intelligence in the myth

518a the intelligent man will still laugh; but will also consider

518d an art for turning around; so it’s not two powers, one intelligence the other sight, but the same object with different orientations, which is different from before saying knowledge and opinion are different powers based off on different things

525a difference between arithmetics and geometry; 525b art of calculation has two uses

529d true ones, but also movement of true ones; then movement is different from becoming?

531e the end goal is dialectics, dialectic unifies the studies and gives account of them

536c playing; 537a education requires playing; then is Glaucon here educated?

539b now with arguments one shouldn’t play

539d What about yourself! Socrates!

541a ousted from the city

4

543c detour, go back; then what’s the point of the detour, will the argument be the same without the detour? Does the detour change anything?

544c named cities

544e cities arise from dispositions; but dispositions also from cities since we deduce the soul from cities?

545b isn’t it already established?

545d timocracy arises out of aristocracy

546 is this ironical as muses are speaking? Or serious? But in either way it shows how chance would rule

549a a man more stubborn than Glaucon

554d fear

561c cephalus

562a fair in a ironic way

573c love as madness; is this the love we talk about previously?

575d another genesis of the tyrant

576a no true friendship

581b a hierarchy of love and pleasures

582 wisdom is the only thing able to judge, hence wisdom alone provides the means of proving itself pleasurable, that is, wisdom alone can defend itself; and wisdom will also rule out other options on the ground that others lack the experience and is not prudent

586 is it a milder pleasure, a pleasure that is lesser, or a mere absence of pain? What about the cave, staring at the sun causes pain? And isn’t to eat more than enough causing more pain as well? Is it really pure pleasure? Can’t it be pure pain?

587e calculation

5

595a imitation brought back, but isn’t imitation of the good allowed previously? And Socrates himself likes referencing poetry, like lotus-eating or direct quotations. Is Plato himself imitating?

596c the man who masters everything is the unjust man?

597a what about themselves who just made a city in speech? According to 598a only alternative is they are imitative of nature but not imitators

597d making couches two retrospectively posits oneness; a discontinuity between God’s free Intention and a necessity independent of even God

598b imitation of looks and imitation of truth

599e then to whom should your city be thankful?

602c does it mean imitation is a third power?

603b intercourse? Eros

603c it was mentioned that a natural sound might be imitated

604d chance

607c we are charmed by poetry; 607d an apology of poetry

608d immortality of soul starts to be related; then what about the previous degeneration of the city? Is degeneration different from what is depicted below? Is something saved from it?

610d seems like a shaky argument, since that a soul might become unjust due to death doesn’t necessarily mean injustice will bring death; but on second look, this is actually a different argument, that since that which dies has to die from its own badness, then external badness has to become internal, then it must be proven it’s injustice itself that is killing the soul; but isn’t it the case that death in the normal sense has already been excluded from counting as the deterioration of the soul? That is, even if it’s shown how injustice kills the man, we can still say what’s killed is the body but not the soul; this is an invincible argument as the death of the soul cannot be perceived.

611a what of divine procreation? Or is immortal strictly selfsame?

612a another allusion to feast; uncertain still if the soul is many-formed or not, only looked at a soul in human life

612e seeming and being reconnected

614c a journey of the soul, the third time in Plato

617b siren’s song; 617e god is blameless, what does it mean “virtue is without a master?”; soul that lives a day, what about immortality?

618b a soul can become different due to its choice

620a pitiable, laughable to see; tragedy!