Gui Ruiyan

Plato · 柏拉图
Timaeus · 蒂迈欧

Undated 未注日期

Timaeus — Reading notes

Reflections · Apple Notes

Revised 27 October 2023

In this note / 篇目

1

17a a beginning of counting; the missing one

17c the best regime

18a republic

19a place to disperse and place to return

19b incompleteness of the account

19c best city at movement; deeds

19e a mysterious statement; how is imitation unsuited for something it’s not nourished upon when imitation is for that which is not? And how is it easier in deed than in speech?

20b trust many people?

20c after what is ordered was spoken of

20e a distant account; time and destruction of mankind

21a a story “just and true”

21d an unfinished account brought from Egypt; an account that didn’t survive

22b an attempt to count the periods of time; you Greeks are never old in soul

22d truth is a shifting of heavenly bodies

23a writing preserves things

23c the best men; forgotten best things; without giving voice to themselves in writing

23e the old best city is 1000 years older than the Egypt city; how are the deeds known?

24a sequence at a later time; now the writings themselves

24c attention to the cosmos; first the order, second the settlement; the goddess is a philosopher

25a standing alone, by necessity; why so many qualifiers?

25d sank beneath the earth; Atlantis

26a divine quirk of chance; has to recover the account first on one’s own

26b setting down an account as foundation

26c recollections of things long past, easier than things that happen only yesterday; a painting, is it now in movement?

26d a story now carried into truth

27a keep my peace; Timaeus is astronomical, has a specific task to inquire the All

27b as before judges

27d without birth? Invocations of our own power

28a being and becoming; intellection and rational account vs opining and irrational sensation; what comes to be has a cause

28b the craftsman; a “begotten” model; what kind of craft is this? Is it farming(generation), making(fabrication), imitation or...war(khora)?

29a the poet(maker) and father(generator) of all

29b a beginning in accordance with nature

29c affinity of accounts to things

29d judges and the speaker have a human nature; no beyond

29e is Timaeus here speaking of the cause?

30c cosmos as an animal that contains other animals akin; the animal both as a model and a copy

31b the animal in all its uniqueness

31c fire and earth for its body

32a the cosmos in mean proportion

32c cosmos came to agree with itself, had friendship, come together with itself in self-sameness

33b an animal that has no outside; whole of all wholes; free from old age and sickness

34a the motion of spinning that suits prudence; reproduction?

34b soul covers body

35b the mixing of kinds to construct soul

37a the circling motion of the soul; touches Same, Other and Being and transmits the message to the soul as a whole, without sound or noise

37e moving likeness of eternity; time; unmoving image: a dream image

38c dissolution of time

38d guardians of time, bodies are only set to the circuit of the Other

39a bodies were needed for the fashioning of time

39e the animal is only similar to itself, but not to the animals it embraces, the many looks of that animal that is

40c guardian and craftsman of night and day

41a willing?

41b not immortal but not dissoluble

41d “bowl”; human souls are of a different constitution than cosmos

42a organ of time; necessity

42b subject to what comes and goes in and out of the body; not subject to body

43a borrow elements from cosmos; rivets invisibly small

43b circuits were swept along and did sweep

44a before only one motion, then with the planets two, and now with human body six and the prior left-right opposition can be reversed

44b affections master the soul circuits even the circuits seem to move along and master

44c the circuits are settled down more as time goes by

44d travel along

45a a traveling head

46d assistant causes

46e moves and be moved only out of necessity; but it’s necessary for the thoughtful to think of thoughts

47b number and time; a gift from gods

47c time and number and vision as an access from the human soul to the cosmic soul

47d attunement and rhythm

48a necessity vs intellect

48b wandering cause; a new beginning

2

48e a passage from narration to decree

49b the third kind: a receptacle for becomings

49d a circle of matter’s becoming

50a “this” or “that” is used to refer to that in which things individually show themselves and from which they perish; whereas the things are addressed as “of that sort”

50c even “of this sort” is a bit shaky

50d a different father than the craftsman; that which comes to be is a nature in-between?

50e a Kind free of Forms

51b a shapeless form; related to the intelligible in a most perplexing way

51e the difference between true opinion and intellect punctuates the being of forms; both true opinions and intellect come to be, but in different ways

52b khora; bastard reasoning with the aid of insensibility; where?

52c the unsleeping nature; khora is what we look to and dream; holding fast to Being

52d the true account is the helper of what genuinely is

53a disequilibrium of powers; purification

53b now before that time; traces of themselves

53d fire, water, air and earth are bodies

53e origins still loftier

55d but earth is also made of triangles incompatible with others; why malleable?

56c invisibly small

57c bodies pass into one another kind either being totally dissolved or mastered by the powerful

57e we have to be observers to see the variety of triangles that constitute bodies

58a motion is non-uniform

58b the circuit of the all squeezes all things together

59a fire, the craftsman of non-uniformity

59d bury the story of things that always are but pursue likely stories of becomings

61d non-linearity; sensings have to accompany affections from the start

63d weight is nothing but attraction to the kindred

64a pleasure and pain

64b unsensed affection; an affection that does not move the bodily particles

64e vision’s fire is so light that there’s no pleasure and pain induced

3

69b a finish and a head

69d evil

72a even divination is of different kinds and is irrational, interpretations require reason

The soul is settled in body; but body is also affecting the soul

73a a receptacle for the superfluous

73c a universal seed stuff made of all smooth triangles

73d who is this god?

74a why the fuck did Aristotle claim brain to be only a cooler when Plato knew it was where soul settled?

74e where reason didn’t show necessity

75c intelligence is in opposition to life

77c plants can feel pleasure, but are not self-moving

77d the body happens to be twofold

80c here it claims there to be no attraction; but that’s not how Timaeus formerly claims to be the case; or perhaps the former attraction is merely the shaking of khora?

84c a natural sequence of bodily development and nutrition; if countered diseases will result

85b epilepsy is not a disease of the soul?

86e no one is willingly bad; rather it’s a disease

88a the soul can also lead to diseases to body

88d imitate the khora

90a upright posture; divine and affinity

90d to attune the understanding to the understood; gift for the time being and the time to come

90e there’s no necessity

91c a wandering womb

91e birds are men who believe truth is firmest from sight