Plato · 柏拉图
Timaeus · 蒂迈欧
Undated 未注日期
Timaeus — Reading notes
Reflections · Apple Notes
Revised 27 October 2023
1
17a a beginning of counting; the missing one
17c the best regime
18a republic
19a place to disperse and place to return
19b incompleteness of the account
19c best city at movement; deeds
19e a mysterious statement; how is imitation unsuited for something it’s not nourished upon when imitation is for that which is not? And how is it easier in deed than in speech?
20b trust many people?
20c after what is ordered was spoken of
20e a distant account; time and destruction of mankind
21a a story “just and true”
21d an unfinished account brought from Egypt; an account that didn’t survive
22b an attempt to count the periods of time; you Greeks are never old in soul
22d truth is a shifting of heavenly bodies
23a writing preserves things
23c the best men; forgotten best things; without giving voice to themselves in writing
23e the old best city is 1000 years older than the Egypt city; how are the deeds known?
24a sequence at a later time; now the writings themselves
24c attention to the cosmos; first the order, second the settlement; the goddess is a philosopher
25a standing alone, by necessity; why so many qualifiers?
25d sank beneath the earth; Atlantis
26a divine quirk of chance; has to recover the account first on one’s own
26b setting down an account as foundation
26c recollections of things long past, easier than things that happen only yesterday; a painting, is it now in movement?
26d a story now carried into truth
27a keep my peace; Timaeus is astronomical, has a specific task to inquire the All
27b as before judges
27d without birth? Invocations of our own power
28a being and becoming; intellection and rational account vs opining and irrational sensation; what comes to be has a cause
28b the craftsman; a “begotten” model; what kind of craft is this? Is it farming(generation), making(fabrication), imitation or...war(khora)?
29a the poet(maker) and father(generator) of all
29b a beginning in accordance with nature
29c affinity of accounts to things
29d judges and the speaker have a human nature; no beyond
29e is Timaeus here speaking of the cause?
30c cosmos as an animal that contains other animals akin; the animal both as a model and a copy
31b the animal in all its uniqueness
31c fire and earth for its body
32a the cosmos in mean proportion
32c cosmos came to agree with itself, had friendship, come together with itself in self-sameness
33b an animal that has no outside; whole of all wholes; free from old age and sickness
34a the motion of spinning that suits prudence; reproduction?
34b soul covers body
35b the mixing of kinds to construct soul
37a the circling motion of the soul; touches Same, Other and Being and transmits the message to the soul as a whole, without sound or noise
37e moving likeness of eternity; time; unmoving image: a dream image
38c dissolution of time
38d guardians of time, bodies are only set to the circuit of the Other
39a bodies were needed for the fashioning of time
39e the animal is only similar to itself, but not to the animals it embraces, the many looks of that animal that is
40c guardian and craftsman of night and day
41a willing?
41b not immortal but not dissoluble
41d “bowl”; human souls are of a different constitution than cosmos
42a organ of time; necessity
42b subject to what comes and goes in and out of the body; not subject to body
43a borrow elements from cosmos; rivets invisibly small
43b circuits were swept along and did sweep
44a before only one motion, then with the planets two, and now with human body six and the prior left-right opposition can be reversed
44b affections master the soul circuits even the circuits seem to move along and master
44c the circuits are settled down more as time goes by
44d travel along
45a a traveling head
46d assistant causes
46e moves and be moved only out of necessity; but it’s necessary for the thoughtful to think of thoughts
47b number and time; a gift from gods
47c time and number and vision as an access from the human soul to the cosmic soul
47d attunement and rhythm
48a necessity vs intellect
48b wandering cause; a new beginning
2
48e a passage from narration to decree
49b the third kind: a receptacle for becomings
49d a circle of matter’s becoming
50a “this” or “that” is used to refer to that in which things individually show themselves and from which they perish; whereas the things are addressed as “of that sort”
50c even “of this sort” is a bit shaky
50d a different father than the craftsman; that which comes to be is a nature in-between?
50e a Kind free of Forms
51b a shapeless form; related to the intelligible in a most perplexing way
51e the difference between true opinion and intellect punctuates the being of forms; both true opinions and intellect come to be, but in different ways
52b khora; bastard reasoning with the aid of insensibility; where?
52c the unsleeping nature; khora is what we look to and dream; holding fast to Being
52d the true account is the helper of what genuinely is
53a disequilibrium of powers; purification
53b now before that time; traces of themselves
53d fire, water, air and earth are bodies
53e origins still loftier
55d but earth is also made of triangles incompatible with others; why malleable?
56c invisibly small
57c bodies pass into one another kind either being totally dissolved or mastered by the powerful
57e we have to be observers to see the variety of triangles that constitute bodies
58a motion is non-uniform
58b the circuit of the all squeezes all things together
59a fire, the craftsman of non-uniformity
59d bury the story of things that always are but pursue likely stories of becomings
61d non-linearity; sensings have to accompany affections from the start
63d weight is nothing but attraction to the kindred
64a pleasure and pain
64b unsensed affection; an affection that does not move the bodily particles
64e vision’s fire is so light that there’s no pleasure and pain induced
3
69b a finish and a head
69d evil
72a even divination is of different kinds and is irrational, interpretations require reason
The soul is settled in body; but body is also affecting the soul
73a a receptacle for the superfluous
73c a universal seed stuff made of all smooth triangles
73d who is this god?
74a why the fuck did Aristotle claim brain to be only a cooler when Plato knew it was where soul settled?
74e where reason didn’t show necessity
75c intelligence is in opposition to life
77c plants can feel pleasure, but are not self-moving
77d the body happens to be twofold
80c here it claims there to be no attraction; but that’s not how Timaeus formerly claims to be the case; or perhaps the former attraction is merely the shaking of khora?
84c a natural sequence of bodily development and nutrition; if countered diseases will result
85b epilepsy is not a disease of the soul?
86e no one is willingly bad; rather it’s a disease
88a the soul can also lead to diseases to body
88d imitate the khora
90a upright posture; divine and affinity
90d to attune the understanding to the understood; gift for the time being and the time to come
90e there’s no necessity
91c a wandering womb
91e birds are men who believe truth is firmest from sight
本文由 AI 从英文原文翻译。请以原文为准。
1
17a 计数的开端;缺席的那一个
17c 最佳政制
18a 理想国
19a 散去之地与归来之地
19b 论述的不完整
19c 运动中的最佳城邦;行动
19e 一句神秘的话;既然模仿所针对的是不在者,为什么模仿会不适于它未曾受其滋养的事物?又为什么在行动中比在言说中更容易?
20b 信任许多人?
20c 在有秩序者被述说之后
20e 遥远的叙述;时间与人类的毁灭
21a 一个“正义而真实”的故事
21d 从埃及带来的未完成叙述;一个未能存留下来的叙述
22b 对时间诸时期的计数尝试;你们希腊人的灵魂从未年老
22d 真理是天体的移位
23a 书写保存事物
23c 最好的人;被遗忘的最好事物;没有通过书写为自己发声
23e 古老的最佳城邦比埃及城邦早一千年;其行动是如何被知晓的?
24a 更晚时候的次序;现在是书写本身
24c 对宇宙的关注;首先是秩序,其次是定居;女神是一位哲人
25a 出于必然,独自站立;为什么有如此多的限定?
25d 沉入大地之下;亚特兰蒂斯
26a 神圣的机缘巧合;必须先自行恢复这一叙述
26b 立下一个叙述作为基础
26c 久远事物的回忆比昨天才发生的事更容易;一幅画,现在进入运动了吗?
26d 一个故事如今被带入真实
27a 保持缄默;蒂迈欧具有天文学素养,负有探究大全的特定任务
27b 仿佛面对裁判
27d 没有诞生?对我们自身力量的祈请
28a 在与生成;理智与理性论述,对照于意见与非理性感觉;生成者有其原因
28b 工匠;一个“生成了的”模型;这是什么样的技艺?是耕种(生育)、制作(制造)、模仿,还是……战争(khora)?
29a 一切的诗人(制作者)与父亲(生育者)
29b 依照自然的开端
29c 论述与事物的亲缘性
29d 裁判与言说者具有人类的本性;没有彼岸
29e 蒂迈欧在这里是在说原因吗?
30c 宇宙作为一个包含其它同类动物的动物;动物同时作为模型与摹本
31b 动物的全部独一性
31c 以火与土构成其身体
32a 处在中比例关系中的宇宙
32c 宇宙与自身达成一致,拥有友爱,在自我同一中与自身会合
33b 一个没有外部的动物;一切整体的整体;免于衰老与疾病
34a 适于审慎的旋转运动;繁殖?
34b 灵魂覆盖身体
35b 混合诸种以构造灵魂
37a 灵魂的环行运动;接触同、异与在,无声无响地把消息传递给作为整体的灵魂
37e 永恒的运动着的相似物;时间;不动的图像:梦的图像
38c 时间的消解
38d 时间的守护者;身体只被安置在异的回环中
39a 时间的塑造需要身体
39e 动物只与自身相似,却不与它所包含的动物相似,也就是那个在着的动物的诸多样貌
40c 昼夜的守护者与工匠
41a 意愿?
41b 并非不朽,却不可消解
41d “碗”;人类灵魂的构成不同于宇宙
42a 时间的器官;必然性
42b 受制于进出身体、来来去去的事物;并非受制于身体
43a 向宇宙借取元素;小到不可见的铆钉
43b 回环被卷走,也卷走其它事物
44a 之前只有一种运动,后来有了行星就有两种,现在有了人体就有六种,而先前左右的对立可以被颠倒
44b 情状支配灵魂的回环,即便回环看似仍在运行并施以支配
44c 随着时间推移,回环愈发安定下来
44d 一同旅行
45a 旅行着的头颅
46d 辅助原因
46e 仅仅出于必然性而运动与被运动;但对思者来说,思考思想是必然的
47b 数与时间;神的赠礼
47c 时间、数与视觉作为人类灵魂通向宇宙灵魂的通路
47d 调谐与韵律
48a 必然性与理智
48b 游荡的原因;一个新的开端
2
48e 从叙述过渡到敕令
49b 第三种:生成者的容器
49d 质料生成的循环
50a “这个”或“那个”用来指称个别事物在其中显现、从其中消逝者;而事物本身则被称作“那一类的”
50c 甚至“这一类的”也有些不稳固
50d 不同于工匠的另一位父亲;生成者是一种居间的本性?
50e 不受形式规定的一种
51b 无形的形式;以最令人困惑的方式与可理智者相关
51e 真意见与理智的差异凸显了形式的在;真意见与理智都会生成,但方式不同
52b khora;在无感觉的辅助下进行的杂种推理;何处?
52c 不眠的本性;khora是我们朝向并梦见者;紧守在
52d 真实的论述是真正在者的助手
53a 力量的不均衡;净化
53b 如今,在那个时候之前;自身的踪迹
53d 火、水、气、土都是身体
53e 还有更高的本原
55d 但土同样由三角形构成,且与其它三角形不相容;为什么可以塑形?
56c 小到不可见
57c 身体要么彻底消解,要么被更强者支配,由此过渡为另一种
57e 我们必须成为观察者,才能看见构成身体的三角形的多样性
58a 运动是不均一的
58b 大全的回环把一切事物挤在一起
59a 火,不均一性的工匠
59d 埋葬关于永远在者的故事,追寻关于生成者的似真故事
61d 非线性;感觉必须从一开始就伴随着情状
63d 重量无非是向同类的吸引
64a 快乐与痛苦
64b 未被感觉到的情状;一种不使身体微粒运动的情状
64e 视觉的火如此轻盈,以至于不引发快乐与痛苦
3
69b 一个完成与一个头
69d 恶
72a 即便占卜也有不同种类,而且是非理性的;解释则需要理性
灵魂安置于身体之中;但身体也在影响灵魂
73a 多余之物的容器
73c 由所有平滑三角形制成的普遍种质
73d 这个神是谁?
74a 柏拉图都知道脑是灵魂安居之所了,亚里士多德他妈的为什么还说脑只是个冷却器?
74e 理性没有显示出必然性的地方
75c 理智与生命相对立
77c 植物可以感受快乐,却不能自行运动
77d 身体恰好是双重的
80c 这里声称没有吸引;但蒂迈欧之前说的并非如此;或者,先前的吸引仅仅是khora的摇动?
84c 身体发育与营养的自然次序;违逆就会导致疾病
85b 癫痫不是灵魂的疾病?
86e 没有人自愿为恶;相反,这是一种疾病
88a 灵魂也可以使身体生病
88d 模仿khora
90a 直立姿态;神圣与亲缘性
90d 让理解与被理解者调谐;给予当下与未来时间的赠礼
90e 没有必然性
91c 游荡的子宫
91e 鸟是那些相信从视觉获得的真理最稳固的人