Gui Ruiyan

Claudius Ptolemy · 克劳狄乌斯·托勒密
Almagest · 至大论

Ptolemy and the Anomalies of Venus

Paper / 论文 · Date from document metadata / 日期据原稿文件信息 · Editorial title / 本版编拟标题

To fulfill what he lays out as the mathematician’s task, Ptolemy will have to explain away the apparent anomalies incurred by Venus via uniform circular motions. The two anomalies are characterized thus in Chapter 2 of Book IX: “one of the anomalies is seen to have relation to the sun, and the other to the parts of the zodiac”. Later, when the motion of Venus is analyzed, this preliminary distinction is delineated in a clearer and more careful way. What the eye observes are, first, Venus sometimes appears to the sun’s west, sometimes its east, seemingly following a periodic pattern, and second, the largest possible angular distances (i.e. largest elongation) between Venus and the mean sun (the difference between the apparent sun and the mean sun is negligible) varies in relation to the location where the complex (Venus in relation to the sun) appears.

In other words, the first anomaly has to do with the fact that as Venus circles around Earth with an average speed equal to the sun, it sometimes overtakes the sun, while at other times falls behind. The second anomaly, on the other hand, states that at two different positions along the circuit traveled by the complex, the largest elongations ever possible of Venus from the sun at those positions will also be different. Here, what I mean by the largest “possible” elongation is that, as the complex is circling around Earth throughout time, it shall reach the same position at every cycle, and Venus in turn shall change its position on its epicycle with respect to the sun every time the complex reaches that position, and Venus will eventually reach the position on its epicycle so that it appears to the eye to be farthest from the sun, and this position constitutes the largest possible elongation. Yet for this second anomaly to stand, it must first be assumed that there is a largest possible elongation of Venus from the sun at any position. This is a hidden assumption that is not carefully established by Ptolemy, for if we were to make the speed that Venus travels on its epicycle the same as the speed that the epicycle itself travels on the deferent, we shall see that except for two positions, there is no position in which Venus will be at its largest possible elongation from the sun, but that when the complex reaches a certain point on the deferent, Venus should also be at a determined position on its epicycle from the sun. Or if the speed of the complex traveling on the deferent shall be a multiple to that of Venus on the epicycle, it is also impossible for there to be a largest possible elongation for any given position. Thus, there is this huge assumption which Ptolemy does not clarify that allows for the later presentation.

Once these two anomalies are clarified, it seems possible to account for them right away, using the extant hypotheses Ptolemy uses to explain the movement of the sun. However, Ptolemy states in Chapter 5 of Book IX, that “immediately on applying the particular positions observed to the courses constructed from the combination of both hypotheses and continually examining them together, we find things cannot proceed so simply”. The major problem he sees in these observations is that, even if a combination of the epicyclical and the eccentric hypotheses is used, there seems to be one other anomaly remaining to be solved.

How does a combination of the two hypotheses solve the first two anomalies? Venus being sometimes to the sun’s west and sometimes to the sun’s east can be accounted for by Venus’ own movement on the epicycle. Since the center of the epicycle moves with a speed equal to that of the mean sun, and the mean sun is not far from the apparent sun, one could say that, when Venus appears to be on the west side to the sun, it is because it has moved to one side of the epicycle, and when it appears to be on the east, it is in turn because it has moved to the other side of the epicycle. The second anomaly can be explained by the eccentric hypothesis, for according to the second hypothesis, Earth is placed slightly off center in the circle on which the complex moves. The effect of this is that one side of the deferent will be farther away from Earth than the other side. Then reasonably on one side of the deferent the complex will appear to the observer larger than when it is on the other side. Therefore, on one side, the largest possible elongation of Venus to the sun will be larger than the largest possible elongation on the other side. By this combination of the two hypotheses, the first two anomalies are resolved.

The third anomaly, it seems to me, is only generated after the introduction of this combined model. Ptolemy talks about it as a discovery from trial and error, but refrains from pinning down its exact nature. Inferring from the consequences the resolution, i.e. the introduction of the equant, brings about into this combined model, one could say that the third anomaly is the complex moves on the deferent by a non-uniform rate. Yet this anomaly would not be fully articulated if not for the pre-establishment of this combined model, by which the complex itself is constructed.

Now, the first two anomalies plus a generated third anomaly can all be resolved theoretically, thus what remains for an account of Venus’s movement to be completed is to find its starting point in observations. What one needs first, then, is a collection of data that records those various largest possible elongations at different positions.

For we see from our study in geometry, that Venus would be at the largest possible elongation from the sun when it is at the intersection between the tangent line from Earth to the epicycle and the epicycle itself, for it is at tangent that the angular distance shall be the greatest. And we also know that geometrically the closer is the complex to Earth, the greater shall be its largest possible elongation as it appears to the observer. And the closest it gets to Earth is when it is on perigee, the farthest away on apogee. Therefore, we could find the apogee and perigee on the deferent through finding where the largest of the largest possible elongations appear. As the line of apsides is determined, so can all the data be ordered on the model. Moreover, by the data one already obtains from observations, the ratio between the radius of the epicycle and that of the deferent can be determined as well, for by following Ptolemy’s steps in geometrical demonstration, one is capable of determining the respective relationships between the linear distances Earth has to the center of the epicycle, the diameter of the deferent and the radius of the epicycle. By these, one is also capable of determining the eccentricity between the center of the deferent and Earth. What is interesting in this procedure is that when Ptolemy is harmonizing the results he obtains respectively from when the complex is at apogee and when the complex is at perigee, he employs a method which one might tentatively call algebraic. For he first assumes one thing (the linear distances from Earth to the center of the epicycle) to be known, and thus makes the thing sought for (the radius of the epicycle) known; when the results on two sides differ, he harmonizes them by establishing two ratios that share one common term. Yet one has to be careful here and see that his method is exactly not algebraic: instead of assuming the thing sought for as known, he makes assumptions only for the starting-points. In other words, his procedure is standard in the sense that he sticks to the formula of positing hypothesis, and starting from the hypothesis reaching for the result, rather than posit the result as something already known.

That said, Ptolemy moves on to determine the eccentricity between the equant, i.e. the center around which Venus moves uniformly, and Earth. He achieves this by selecting a specific position, as he says in Chapter 3 Book X, “when the sun’s mean position was a quadrant’s distance in one direction or the other from the apogee”. Yet, after the data are gathered from observation, he says, before the demonstration starts, that “for the proposed mean position, the greatest morning elongation is assumed to be ... and the evening one ...” (my emphasis and omission)

By this, he is addressing the problem that the largest morning and evening elongations appear unequal. The apparent inequality comes from this third anomaly that is to be resolved by the equant. What is to be noted is that, his interpretation of the data collected by earlier observers here seems to be that the mean sun assumed by them has Earth as the center of movement, and not the deferent. Hence he conveniently arrives at the conclusion that as the mean sun in his model moves a quadrant away from the perigee, so is the mean sun assumed by his predecessors at direct quadrature to Earth. In other words, against the backdrop of Ptolemy’s own template, the data collected by the earlier astronomers appear anomalistic, which results from their hidden assumption that the mean sun moves uniformly about Earth. Only by this interpretation is Ptolemy able to carry out the further calculations, which add the two elongations up to compose of a larger angle, which could decompose into two equal angles, each of which is the elongation. Or, it might not be his “interpretation”, but he intentionally selects those data collected by those who he knows carry such an assumption, to lighten the weight of his labor. Otherwise, if the mean sun is already supposed to move on an eccentric circle, the direct parallelism between the movement of the assumed mean sun about Earth and the movement of the mean sun that fits his model about the center of its movement will be lost (On the diagram on page 315 in Taliaferro’s edition, the parallelism is between the line DE and the dashed line). Without the direct parallelism, the angle between the line connecting Earth to the center of the epicycle and the line connecting the center of uniform movement of the complex to the center of the epicycle (on the diagram that is angle DEB) cannot be easily derived.

There is one other benefit brought about by Ptolemy’s data selection. By choosing the data of mean sun being at quadrature, after the said angle is determined, he could directly apply the chord table to further determine the eccentricity in relation to the linear distance between Earth and the center of the epicycle. Since we also could calculate the ratio between the radius of the epicycle and the distance between Earth and the center of the epicycle, we could determine the eccentricity in relation to the radius of the epicycle. And previously we have determined the eccentricity between the center of the deferent and Earth in relation to the radius of the epicycle, we again could determine the relationship between the two eccentricities. We shall see that the later eccentricity is roughly double the earlier eccentricity. And it is in this way, by these procedures, and under such assumptions, that Ptolemy succeeds in determining those magnitudes related to the movement of Venus.