Gui Ruiyan

Leo Tolstoy · 列夫·托尔斯泰
War and Peace · 战争与和平

Undated 未注日期

The dead meteorite — on Tolstoy's War and Peace

Douban · Bidasari

If we say that war is the ultimate motion, it certainly does not entail that peace is at all peaceful. On the contrary, ‘peace’ only denotes a motion without significance, a general discontentedness and restiveness that have no particular direction nor any human purpose. Peace is that constant flux of the society of flattery, ‘the kingdom of shades’ as called by Tacitus, and as such is acclaimed as ‘our culture.’

Just like a river that flows smoothly into preformed channels, these movements do not cause disturbances, and under normal circumstances stay in their translucent eternity. All high waters remain intact from the mud sedimented at the bottom, jolly and clear. It does not matter whose party it is, Anna Pavlovna Scherer’s or Helene Bezukhova’s, the same rumors are relayed in their entertaining variations, the same jokes cracked and witticisms borrowed. No character is more essential to the circle than any ‘special trophy’ brought in by Anna Pavlovna as a special dinner treat. This is the first world of Tolstoy’s imagination, or rather of his reality.

Compared to the second world, this first world not only seems inauthentic, but also misleading. The transparency of the social world and the utter superficiality of it only conceals the depth underlying. This depth cannot be brought out without the greatest upheavals. The mud that will one day become the good soil of the plain is only stirred up from the riverbed in the midst of most heated conflicts and contradictions.

War, compared to the kingdom of flattery, is the authentic form of life. This war does not consist in the military understood as an organization of the generals and their intrigues, quarrels and maneuvers. Rather, Tolstoy resolutely put this aside as another mere manifestation of peace, when the ground is still and no motion carries any significance: any structure is necessarily a façade that veils the inner truth of motion, for a structure is only possible in peace, that state of both inauthentic motion and inauthentic rest. Prince Bolkonsky understood thus the essence of war: ‘war is not a game of manners.’

Why is the war capable of such a revelation of truth and authenticity? Tolstoy has two answers, though he often conflates the two. First, because war is necessarily a popular effort. This is a simple fact, and Tolstoy is surprised that no one seemed to have noticed this fact. In war, ‘the populace’ comes up which before was hidden and suppressed, unexpressed and sedimented. In wars, unprecedented masses of people are pushed across borders to encounter each other. Seeing all people in their different nationalities, different tongues and classes reduces them to their most basic psychological realities. One thing constantly expressed by soldiers, to their friends and enemies alike, is that ‘one has to be human after all.’ As Pierre observed the battle of Borodino, he thought ‘They are different from Us.’ ‘They’ here is indeed an abstraction, the abstraction of ‘simply human,’ who lead an authentic life. That is also what Platon’s life meant to him: a simple, natural life, detached and abstracted from all cares and appendages, thoroughly opposed, or rather indifferent, to the world of ‘culture.’

But one cannot help but notice here a ruse employed by Tolstoy. It is true that both the French and the Russians are ‘merely human’ and encounter each other as such in war. But compared to the French, the Russians seemed more naturally settled in, more easily in comfort in these states of nature. This is what Tolstoy in some places termed ‘Russianness,’ as opposed to the French ‘culturalism.’ In this way, a certain concreteness is still required even in the deepest abstraction: ‘humanity’ as an abstraction needs to be in itself a concrete force as represented in the body and soul of every Russian, in their popular movement under the exigencies of war. What Tolstoy intends to undertake, then, is the recovery of authentic nature in its full rootedness and earthiness as they reside within the Russian people. The Russian soldiers who, bared of all ‘glorious pursuits’ and ‘heroic illusions,’ fulfill only their ‘trivial’ duties. The Moscovites’ silent resistance in abandoning Moscow simply out of the care of their own property, in contrast to Rostopchin’s histrionic zealotry, etc. More than anything, as Natasha, in the best and most brilliant section of the book, joins the hunt or dances out of her own enjoyment, she is depicted as a goddess of ‘pure Russianness’ incarnate; whilst this Russian goddess is allured and captured by the westernized coquette Helene and her brother in an opera house.

Has Tolstoy, by any chance, carried out his full intention? Has he, deploying all his faculties and genius, managed to work out all the intricate layers and webs of popular life? Painstaking and assiduous as it is, anyone who has read War and Peace cannot deny that something feels amiss with this book in this respect, the outer manifestation of which is the author’s unrestrained theoretical loquacity. This loquacity (this must be stressed) stems not from any genuine polemic against the ‘historians’ as such, for neither his theory of history is much more enlightening nor his historical analyses any more concrete than those he criticized, but from an inability to delve into the reality of popular social forces and psychology. His theoretical and abstractive attitude and his direct engagement with the ‘historians’ are nothing more than a diversion from the true task that lays ahead of him of materializing the intricate networks and dynamics of society, which he evades to tackle as much as possible. Indubitably, there are moments where he exceeds the cage he sets for himself and exudes rare brilliance, but for such a monstrously long book, it is not impossible to make some good shots in the dark.

Compare the moment when in Middlemarch, a book much less ambitious on the surface, the peasants confront Caleb Garth, or even in Odyssey when the swineherd pities Odysseus or when his nurse recognizes him from a scar, one sees how feebly the social reality is really touched on by Tolstoy. Though brilliant moments and details from War and Peace perhaps outweigh those details added up from both works, the ratio and purity become inconspicuous in comparison, undermined by the author’s theoretical ‘zeal,’ i.e. his impotence. Or compare with those French masters of realism, e.g. Victor Hugo, Balzac, Zola, can one not see how deprived of life this unwieldy work turns out to be?

Let us quickly examine some examples. There is a scene in War and Peace similar to the confrontation between Caleb Garth and the peasants, namely, the confrontation between Marya and her villagers. There are some remarkable differences between the two. First, peasants in that scene in Middlemarch have a reasonable and valid motive, since they see and experience clearly the advent of the modern world brought forth in the railway, whereas it is never clear why those in War and Peace should betray the Russians besides their stupidity making them an easy dupe. Next, because of the intelligibility of their motive, Caleb Garth is genuinely struck by their eloquent presence, whereas the peasants in the other scene become mere background material for Nikolai’s chivalry and venting of rage. Finally, as in Middlemarch more limelight is put on the group as a whole, in War and Peace the force of the story is focused on the personal tragedy of the village Elder. It is not difficult to see which scene is more illuminative.

Somewhere in the book, as if to recompense the lack, Tolstoy devoted a whole chapter describing the errand into town of the old prince’s servant. Yet there the servant has scanty interactions with the pub owner or anyone else, and his speech, when he speaks at all, is limited to his despise for the womenfolk. As anywhere else, this character is impenetrable to us.

Tolstoy’s depiction of camp life is generally more satisfactory, as soldiers in war represent for him the authentic life that faces death immediately. Yet these scenes are still too transient and nebulous, for we see the soldiers’ movements and expressions, yet they present themselves only as ‘types’ or ‘groups’, but not as concretely associated individuals with their own inner complexities and psychological realities. At best, the motives of their actions are hinted at, which most often do not exceed that of their lust, their boredom, their simple patriotism and their pity for the merely human. Even in one of the most genuine scenes, where the rescued French captain Ramballe and other Russian soldiers learn to sing together, a higher heaven of stars overhangs them. It is Tolstoy’s genius that he does not forget to make one soldier remark, staring at the brilliant stars: ‘Next year we will have a good harvest.’ Such moments, however, are still too rare, and too tarnished by the author’s grandiloquent prolixity.

But who can say this is not another of Tolstoy’s clever tricks, since this is exactly his point: just as Napoleon does not command his army, an author does not command his work. Or rather, just as Napoleon ‘ought not to’ command his army, an author ‘ought not to’ select, purify, refine and adorn his work? His impotence then perhaps would turn out to be a most eloquent rhetorical argument against all kinds of ‘culture’ and ‘genius’?

In truth, whence comes this author’s incapability? Could this be a social or class limitation imposed on the author, that as an aristocrat he is simply and utterly segregated from the ‘populace’ mentally and spiritually? This is the laziest and most uninteresting answer one could give. For now, we tentatively accept Machiavelli’s maxim: ‘only a prince understands a people, just as only a people understand the prince.’

No one has understood the people better than Tolstoy. Tolstoy sees the crisis of modernity that has taken Europe, and more than anything, this crisis has spread to Russia. The authentic life of the Russian people is threatened by this crisis, whose representatives are the Westernizers and, in the narrative, the France sympathizers. It is not to be denied that Tolstoy’s position on the issue of modernity is much subtler (see the sarcastic tongue Tolstoy used in describing the French who ‘adulates’ Russia), but we do not need to delve into this too much. What is to be acknowledged here is simply that the Russian people are threatened by the expansion of the West, and an authentic, natural life as the Russians live has been uprooted. The ominous character of Platon’s death could not say more.

Everything is distorted and spoiled in culture. The old countess and Boris’ mother, who ‘wept together out of commiseration for their childhood memories and their strenuous friendship,’ become estranged as soon as their positions are reversed. Needless to mention the tragedy between Andrei and Natasha. Even Sonya, who is good and kind, is a ‘pet’ (the ‘cat’, the ‘kitten’) kept outside the natural family, the ‘infertile flower’ artificially raised. And it is against such a culturalism the war is to be waged: not a war between Napoleon and his virtuous counterpart Alexander I, but a war between Napoleon, i.e. his mirage and ghost army, and Russian life.

If war reveals the spiritual strife, it does not resolve it by itself. Masses of people encounter each other on the battleground and are provided a chance to meet each other authentically, yet war is still war. The animosity, the intrigues and conflicts all pose as obstacles against a genuine resolution.

For Tolstoy, spiritual peace is no longer genuinely possible among people. The very existence of social relations posits ‘culture.’ People are volatile, they are easily swayed by passion, at once intense hatred, but as soon as the atrocity is done, they feel pity. Soldiers are commanded to kill against their natural sympathy, and Napolean consciously restrains his humanity: the disease of culture has, at this point, become inveterate. That is why Platon is an outlier and seems mysterious, and why the draconic Marya Dmitriyevna Akhrosimova is universally feared. They can only be side characters and idols to be revered, but not direct objects of the narrative.

But this is still an abstraction. Why is it impossible to spend more ink on those characters that seem to illustrate what a genuine life is? Why must these characters be shrouded in a mystical light? After all, is not that hunting and that Christmas breathtakingly genuine and beautiful? Tolstoy’s evasion still seems insufficiently explained.

As always, when there is a negative repulsion, there is a positive attraction. As characteristic of the whole genre of ‘disillusionment,’ among the debris of a ruined social life, Tolstoy seeks solace in the most private, the most inner, and the most transcendent: death.

This is the second revelation war brings, the simplest and most natural of all phenomena: the comfort of nothingness. In death nature is rediscovered. The natural but unreachable expanse of heaven Andrei stares at bewilderingly and the immediate pity he feels for Anatole both herald a rediscovery of the natural world. Love, of course, performs the same function: that tree newly sprouting signifies a rejuvenation of Andrei’s life, whilst the comet of 1812 does the same for Pierre. What war brings primarily out of men, love brings out of men in relation to women. And just as war easily flips to the side of inauthenticity and violence, love easily degenerates into coquetry and abductions by passion.

For now, we delay the question of love, and focus only on war. War turns men inside themselves. When Andrei looks at the naked bodies (the ‘white flesh’) of his soldiers cramped in a pond, he thinks of the word ‘cannon fodder,’ and he looks at his own body, realizing his own bodily insignificance. Death excludes culture, and in this exclusion expresses the ultimate nature: death is where peace truly lies. If the title of this work has a spiritual meaning, this meaning is none other than ‘war and death.’ Andrei has attained to this truth in his last days, and Pierre in his imprisonment approaches it. But if death is irrepresentable qua the ultimate tranquility, then certainly Tolstoy should not be able to depict the essence of authentic life, since the only one possible now is an inner death. Platon’s death, then, is not a tragedy, and Pierre turns away from him not only because he is at that point heartless and exhausted, but also because he intuitively perceives the inner truth revealed by this event. To live like Platon is to not live. The same life, the living of death, is possible anywhere: it is to live like an animal, and Platon’s spirit lives on within the stray dog with bandy legs that follows behind. Not only are men animals, but men ‘ought to’ live like animals, acknowledging their own finitude. Like that ‘working lad’ convict who finds the most comfortable posture to die, in facing death one finds genuine peace.

What about love? Apparently, love in the end triumphs. Life continues, and those deaths and what they might mean are stashed away. Nevertheless, we must perceive here that this love, love in its authentic form of marriage and friendship, is but a different name for mourning. The death of Andrei enshrines him, and for the whole family in the epilogue, especially for his son, he becomes a household divinity. Marya, when she reflects upon her life, determines that in her waiting of Andrei’s death ‘some mysterious experience has opened forth, which she could never aspire to again.’ The one most untroubled by Andrei’s memory in the household, Nicolai, is nonetheless haunted by him, in the shape of Pierre’s political views and his nephew, and he treasures the memory of the war. To live on earth is to live a life of incessant mourning for the loss of that real, true and beautiful life, that is revealed in war in the form of death. And herein lies the cause of Tolstoy’s impotence: not that he is incapable of illustrating the vibrancy and rhythm of popular and communal life which he deems to be the ideal and authentic life, but because he no longer believes this kind of natural life is possible to last, and is thus desperate to provide an antidote for the crisis of modernity threatening the Russian people: that is a life of mourning, of longing for death, and thus of the minimal activity, a life devoid of passion, a life consisting only of duties and musts. This is a life of transcendence and tranquility, which necessarily contradicts the infinitesimal movement of history. As history is only a backdrop for providence, it has no life of its own.