Gui Ruiyan

Paper / 论文 ·

Technique and Expression: An Inquiry into the Paradox of the Art of Counterpoint

A preliminary justification is in due order on behalf of the method of this inquiry. For it is not uncommon a presupposition for music lovers that the living experience of listening should be privileged over the intellectual analysis based on a written score. And if the method, to start with, of our analysis is crippled, how can any of its consequent arguments survive intact? In what way could we shelter our methodology, and claim in confidence that our method, i.e. approaching music through its written representation, fits its musical object?

Our musical object at hand is a piece of counterpoint music, e.g. Introitus from St. Matthew Passion by Heinrich Schütz, and the aspect we are interested in is its employment of the art of counterpoint. There are two ways to approach this piece, one by listening to it attentively, the other by reading it closely on a score. To be sure, these two methods are in no case mutually exclusive, and they are necessarily interdependent. For without the living experience, the analysis cannot be related to the musical reality, and all its subtleties that can only be expressed through the enlivened music are lost. Yet without the analysis, the subjective experiences retained from the actual listening cannot be communicated and justified in the face of other equally subjective, hence legitimately musical, experiences. This is the fundamental paradox that primarily haunts our musical mind and ear.

However, the issue runs even deeper with the art of counterpoint. An example shall elucidate the dilemma. With Scarborough Fair, which is a relatively “simple” piece (in the sense that it is monophonic), if the performer accidentally lowers the B in the seventh measure (“ma-ry”) by a half step, simply by ear an unacquainted listener could detect the Doric flavor of the piece impaired. To restore the integrity of this piece, she would simply with courtesy ask the performer to raise that note by a half step. Yet with Introitus by Schütz, even if our ear detects something wrong about the performance, it is much more difficult for us to pinpoint that specific note going wrong without former acquaintance with the piece. And even if we could, without a written score lying before us, we would be confused as to how to rectify the foil without detriment to the whole.

The art of counterpoint, in a sense, is essentially founded on a formalization of music through the establishment of written composition. For this art is by its nature concerned with harmonization of separate pieces into a structural whole, which exceeds our living experience of the moment, and presents itself in the light of the eternal. This dimension is perceived as most evident in Zarlino’s writing. In Chapter 1, he defines the art of counterpoint as that which “teaches one to recognize the various elements in a composition and to arrange the sounds with proportional ratios and temporal measure”. In Chapter 10, he avers that “the consonances are arranged according to the nature of the sonorous number because they are placed in their natural positions”. For him, what determines the qualities of consonances (hence also dissonances) is their nature that is mathematically fixed. Therefore, to arrange the sounds “with proportional ratios and temporal measure” means to deploy these determinate relations of tones ordained by their numerical nature into a temporal order that determines the whole. Time as a temporal order, however, is not time as how we usually experience it in our daily life, but is rather a structure that is measured temporally. Instead of giving an impression that soon passes away, it endures through time and over time. Measurement of time is one of the greatest difficulties that puzzles Augustine in his investigations. How is it possible for time to be measured, which is composed of parts that either exists no more or has not yet existed? One practical solution that musicians discover is to put musical time into a static image, and measure it by its length. In other words, the temporality with which the art of counterpoint is preoccupied is only a temporality represented in spatial terms, i.e. on a score.

Experience and art support each other in a reciprocal interdependence. Whilst artists produce by their technique, the aesthetic value judgments they receive from the audience spur them on in turning back and modifying their theory of production. This works the same with the art of counterpoint. The rules that Zarlino formulates have to rely on trial and error in experience. In Chapter 28, he claims that “musicians in the past, as well as the best of the moderns, believed that a counterpoint or other musical composition should begin on a perfect consonance... but they did not believe the rule to be inviolable, that no composition could ever begin with an imperfect consonance”. Theory is modified or reconciled by practice. In the realm of music, our lived experience is the ultimate judge. Nevertheless, for the practice of counterpointing, even as experience is necessitated in order to provide the basis for the initiation of each rule and the modifiability of each, a detachment from experience is in turn necessitated if it wants to establish itself not merely as a practice, but as an artful practice, for an art is directed at the produced object as a whole, despite the unique standing a musical object takes regarding experience. In fine, practice harbors in itself an equivocation between experience and the art that guides it. On the one hand, practice has to agree with how we feel in the process of experiencing the music and modify its art accordingly if necessary, whilst on the other, it has to stay away from immersion into the moment and turn its gaze upon the whole. The way practice does it is through writing on a paper, and it is allegedly at this moment that music wears on the manacle of death.

Let us read Chapter 26 in Zarlino’s book. “The subject of every composition is that part of a composition upon which the composer exercises his inventiveness to produce the other parts, however many voices these may be”. The composer is first presented with a determinate product as finished, what Zarlino calls “the subject”, and proceeds from there by art of counterpoint. But the living experience of a melody is always indeterminate in its passing away. Experience thus provides no firm basis, no “cantus firmus”, on which the work could be built. This infirmity would be detrimental, for counterpointing is in its essence a polyphonic art. Polyphonicity dictates that each part of the piece written against the other part through the art of counterpoint should itself constitute an independent melodic whole. In our lived experience, we could easily determine if a chord sounds consonant or dissonant without the help of a score, yet that is no guarantee that each note that composes this chord would melodically harmonize with its preceding and succeeding notes in the same line. Our living experience is restricted in the moment, so that we are able to judge if the current chord is a consonance or a dissonance, but unprovided with a score, we would be obfuscated, if not utterly resourceless, in determining if the higher note of the chord fits into the melodic line of the higher part of the piece, much less if it fits into the piece as a whole. Thus one could say that especially for polyphony and the art of counterpoint, a written composition would be indispensable.

Its importance also lies in another aspect. In Schütz’s Introitus, starting from the tenth measure, waves of similar melodies succeed one another. In the experience lived by the listener, this creates a feeling of ordered recurrence. This order, however, is impossible without the measure imposed by the artist onto the piece through the art of counterpoint. Only through a written composition, is one able to order the sequence, i.e. where each part should come in, without impairing the overall balance of ratio between consonance and dissonance that is required of a polyphonic piece. This is the reverse of the earlier practice. Before, one starts with the subject and attempts to write counterpoints that in turn constitute a complete and independent melody. Here, one starts with similarly given melodies that are supposed to imitate one another, and attempts to vertically weave them together into an ordered whole. Either way, one can clearly see the necessity of written composition for counterpointing.

Thus it is not only appropriate, but also necessary that one should primarily approach a counterpuntal piece through its written objectification, since some of its most essential determinations are only revealed in its score. But what we have gone over just now is far from a simple methodological discussion. If the method should fit its object, then by determining our method, dialectically we have also determined the nature of our object. This we succeed in doing, for we have established that a counterpuntal piece is by nature “best” represented through the artist’s written composition. And the paradox that so far leads our inquiry into the methodological aspect also lies inherent in the object. For even as we listeners, being aestheticians and critics of music, are unsure of our approach to the piece, and are worried whenever we either let the intellect subdue the ear, or make our subjective experience dominating universal judgment, this dilemma is as confirmed for composers. The split between technique and expression is wide, and is at its widest when touching on the subject of dissonance.

The usage of the term “expression” needs some clarification here. For expression can mean three different things: self-expression, musical expression, and emotive expression; for expression occurs when either a musician expresses herself through her music, or the music expresses some universal meaning, or the music helps the listener find his own expression of himself. I have treated experience as equivalent to this third category, hence expression as I use it includes only the first two categories, though it is doubtful to me if any of those most renowned polyphonic composers, e.g. Palestrina, ever considered his music an expression of his self-hood.

Counterpoint is first described by Zarlino in Chapter 1 as one “artful union of diverse sounds reduced to concordance”. Hence, it is the highest objective of this art to contain diversity. The rub here, however, is that if the diversity is not extreme enough, there would be no need for any art of unification or reduction. The art of reduction feeds on what is well nigh irreducible, and this is the productive paradox for the art of counterpoint. The technique, by this token, will have to incorporate into itself elements from an expression that exceeds the simplicity and perfection of a unity. The tension between multiplicity and simplicity is witnessed by Zarlino in Chapter 8. Consonances are “ ‘fuller’ which are closer to their origin and are more perfect than the others” but “more ‘pleasing’ as they depart from simplicity”. Not only this, there is an even further differentiation within the perfect consonances, that “among the perfect, the fifth is more ‘pleasing’ than the octave, and the fourth more ‘pleasing’ than the fifth... for they are more removed from equality”. Defying the monotonous simplicity of the absolute perfect, music finds its expression in a pleasantness that stems from multiplicity.

Is this not another version of Augustine’s theology, that evil is non-existent, merely a privation or a finite imitation of the Good, and a cosmos that is composed of both the highest things and things that are less high is far superior than one that is composed only of the highest things? Dissonances are not meaningless noises, and imperfect consonances are not undesirable, but are all rather expressive. Their expressiveness lies either in their “sweetness” or their jarring effect of alienation. The technique, then, is to make use of this expressiveness and control it, for these expressions so far remain only singular and irreducibly indeterminate, being yet to be contextualized into a whole. It is only through the technique that these various expressions can be transformed into parts of a harmoniously expressive musical object.

Notwithstanding their interdependence as such obtains between form and material, technique is distanced from expression as such. Technique remains more or less concealed in our lived experience with music. The moment it becomes most relevant to us is when music itself perishes, when the musical reality itself is congealed into its dead representation, for technique treats music not as the temporal experience as is lived by us, but as the objectified representation of such experience. Yet it is uncanny for thought how music itself is preserved by and blossoms through its own corpse, how it grows out of the bare-boned machinery behind the illusionistic sceneries. For, not only is music produced through these mechanisms, but some of its most essential aspects are only revealed through these intellectual determinations on a score, as we have previously established. Zarlino comments on this paradox in Chapter 40 as if this is nothing surprising, and here I will quote him extensively:

“I give here general rather than particular rules for writing a counterpoint upon a subject. The composer must arrive at the contrapuntal part by means of the previously given rules by exercising his own intellect and judgment. Unless nature has given him these, rules and precepts will avail him little. But here is nothing surprising in my method. It holds in every art and branch of learning, for all who have attempted to teach an art or science has begun with universals. It is in these rather than in innumerable particulars that science consists.”

His indifferent and unsurprised attitude at the uncanny split between technique and expression is exactly what is surprising. However, perhaps one should not read this through the lens of a modern aesthete, who considers the split between creation and its laws unbridgeable. The Greek ἀρχαί are not to be understood as a set of static laws, but are themselves dynamic sources of creation whence the particulars spring forth. And this conception of principles might be applied to the passage above as well. The truth of his opinion on this subject, therefore, remains to be determined.